Senate plan keeps heat on for Lake income tax

Font Size:

BY PATRICK GUINANE
pguinane@nwitimes.com
317.637.9078 | Wednesday, February 20, 2008 | (10 comment(s))

INDIANAPOLIS | State Senate leaders put their stamp on property tax relief efforts Tuesday, adding to the mix local income tax options that most counties, including Lake and Porter, rejected last year.

The proposal retains the core aspects of Gov. Mitch Daniels' plan to reduce homeowner property taxes by roughly a third, in part by raising the state sales tax a penny, from 6 percent to 7 percent. But Republican Senate leaders want local officials to contribute to the cause, saying most homeowners could see their annual tax bills cut in half if counties impose a 0.5 percent income tax dedicated to property tax relief.

The Senate plan, now contained in House Bill 1001, also would phase in over two years the property tax caps proposed by Daniels. The move would give local government until 2010 to face the full brunt of $619 million in spending cuts that would be forced by the caps.

Lake County by far remains the hardest hit by the so-called circuit breaker, with local government and schools set to lose $205 million next year under the Senate plan and $262 million in 2010. The proposed phase-in would cost Porter County $510,000 next year and $8 million in 2010.

Counties that impose a property tax relief income tax of at least 0.25 percent could, under the Senate plan, hike the tax another 0.25 percent to offset police and fire budget cuts caused by the property tax caps.

Lake County would remain under last year's legislative mandate to impose a 1 percent income tax for property tax relief. But senators have included the three new income tax distribution formulas under review by the Lake County Council.

The Senate plan, which cleared committee Tuesday on a 9-0 vote, also would create a "distressed unit" appeal board to hear funding pleas from local governments ravaged by the tax caps. Senate Tax Chairman Luke Kenley, R-Noblesville, said the state panel, which he likened to a bankruptcy court, could help Whiting cope with an expected loss of roughly $2.5 million.

Another new wrinkle added Tuesday would set aside $50 million a year to restore some of the funding schools would lose to the phased-in tax caps. Statewide, those school losses are projected at $91 million next year and $189 million in 2010.

"Schools don't have a way to make up their losses under the circuit breaker," Kenley said. "In the Senate, for the first time, we are recognizing that's an issue."

The Senate plan drops plans to double the state income tax deduction for renters and boost by 50 percent the earned-income tax credit, a move designed to benefit lower-income families. Both were added by the Democratic-controlled House.

"I really think it's a much more realistic plan," said Sen. Sue Landske, R-Cedar Lake. "We really do have the money to fund this plan. The plan that came over from the House was a little over budget."

FUNDING SWAPS
Instead of assuming $500 million in local school transportation costs, as Gov. Mitch Daniels has proposed, the Senate plan unveiled Tuesday would have the state spend $386.4 million a year on the following categories. Here's the breakdown:
$123.6 million in local school pension debt
$90 million in local pensions for police and firefighters hired prior to 1977
$50 million to offset budget cuts schools face under proposed tax caps
$22.8 million in juvenile incarceration costs now covered by counties
$100 million for additional tax credits to homeowners

Senate, Daniels' plans compared
How the Senate tax relief blueprint advanced Tuesday squares up with the plan Gov. Mitch Daniels released last fall.
IMPACT
Daniels: 33 percent cut in homeowner property taxes.
Senate: Cut homeowner taxes by at least a third, or perhaps in half if counties OK income taxes.
TAX HIKES
SALES
Daniels: Penny state sale tax hike, from 6 percent to 7 percent.
Senate: Same.
INCOME
Daniels: County option taxes available as "last resort."
Senate: Counties encouraged to adopt 0.5 percent income tax for property tax relief. If they do, they could impose 0.25 percent income tax to fund public safety -- police, fire, etc.
CIRCUIT BREAKER
Daniels: Constitutionally cap tax bills at 1 percent of assessed value for homeowners, 2 percent for rental properties and 3 percent for businesses, beginning in 2009.
Senate: Phase in the cap over two years. The circuit breaker would be 1.5 percent next year for homeowners, 2.5 percent for landlords and 3 percent for businesses. Caps would go to 1, 2 and 3 percent in 2010.
ASSESSMENT
Daniels: Get rid of all 1,100 elected assessors -- have each county appoint one assessor.
Senate: Keep the 92 county assessors and 44 local assessors in townships that handle more than 15,000 parcels.
CONSTRUCTION
Daniels: Let voters decide via referendum whether costly school and local government projects go forward.
Lawmakers: The same, but referendum-approved projects would not be subject to tax caps.
COST SHIFTS
Daniels: Have state government assume $3 billion in child welfare and school operating costs.
Senate : Have state pick up about $2.5 billion in school and welfare expense. But instead of assuming $500 million in school transportation costs, state would take on $340 million in juvenile incarceration costs, teacher pension bonds and municipal police and fire pensions for employees hired before 1977.
SPENDING CONTROLS
Daniels: Limit local government spending increases to annual growth in personal income (2.9% in Lake, 4.6% in Porter).
Senate: No hard spending caps, but repeal 18 property tax levy appeals local government now use to boost spending, including the annexation appeal Valparaiso used last year.
SCHOOLS
Daniels: Statewide, schools would lose about $170 million a year to his tax caps.
Senate: State would spend $50 million a year to offset school cuts caused by phased-in caps.

Back to story 10 comment(s)

Please note: Comments from readers will be screened and may not be posted immediately. If you don't see your comment perhaps:

It wasn't clear, concise or focused on the topic in the story.
It was a personal attack, vulgar, explicit or degrading, used actual or implied profanity or contained potentially libelous statements.
It accused someone of being guilty of a crime.
It promoted violence or illegal acts.
It contained telephone numbers or street addresses, or e-mail addresses and links to Web sites other than nwi.com or government agencies.

In no way do these comments represent the views of The Times or Lee Enterprises.

Passionate views, pointed criticism and critical thinking are welcome. Name-calling, crude and profane language and personal abuse are not welcome.

Reader comments will not be edited - they will be approved or declined. They may be used in the print edition of the newspaper.

If you feel a posted comment has violated these guidelines, please email our New Media team the commenter's name, the comment and a link to the article.

For more information please read our Terms of Service.

venus58 wrote on Feb 26, 2008 2:19 PM:

" It is absolutely ridiculous that the cuts that Governor Daniels proposed have been so watered down through the House and now the Senate. Get rid of all the assessors...they can't do their jobs anyway. Notice how the powerhouses have made it so the larger parceled areas will retain their township assessors. Also, the Senate has made "No Hard Caps" for spending cuts. Make these suckers fiscally responsible by voting all of them out next election. VOTE REPUBLICAN in Lake County and freak'em All out...it's the only way! "

Concerned Citizen wrote on Feb 21, 2008 8:55 AM:

" So the people who are WORKING are going to pay another tax to keep the other people not working. We should vote out every politician in Lake County and force the new ones to reduce the waste in Lake County. Go throught he Government building in Crown Point and see how many people are sleeping or who actually arent working all day. "

Marc wrote on Feb 20, 2008 9:24 PM:

" Wow. Get a grip. This property tax relief is much more valuable to most of us than a 1% sales tax increase PLUS an increase in income tax (1% for Lake Cty is likely).

"

Angry Mob wrote on Feb 20, 2008 5:33 PM:

" Here is Indiana's current “tax cut” plan:

•Reduce the increase in tax deductible property taxes and shift the entire tax burden to non-deductible sales taxes.

•Increase the local income tax

•Reduces no government spending

•Result: NET TAX INCREASE

The bipartisan government-reform panel led by Indiana Supreme Court Chief Justice Randall Shepard and former Gov. Joe Kernan recommend the elimination of 1,155 units of government and 5,833 fewer elected officials statewide saving $400 million each year.

We've got to quit governing like this!

Message from former Governor Joe Kernan www.indianachamber.com

BSU Study: Kernan-Shepard Recommendations Give Big Savings EACH Year
www.insideindianabusiness.com/newsitem.asp?id=27617
"

BOTH MRVANS wrote on Feb 20, 2008 2:30 PM:

" With any luck we will get rid of both Mrvans in the upcoming elections! Leeches, the word the describes them best. "

Susan wrote on Feb 20, 2008 1:10 PM:

" Hey, Frank Mrvan! Nice job you're doing! "

G Davis wrote on Feb 20, 2008 11:32 AM:

" All these politicians down state are scammers, all they will do is jack up our taxes and we will get nothing for it I lived in Indiana all my life except for when I went to go fight for the Country and Indiana is by far the worst state I have ever seen in my life. Enough is enough the jobs left in Indiana don't leave enough money for anything anymore.where do these bozos think the working poor get money from?The poverty wage jobs that only come to Indiana so they can do what ever they want to their employees?Cabelas for example!And a person cannot get any help from the State when these Anti American companies ruin peoples lives! "

Morons! wrote on Feb 20, 2008 8:33 AM:

" Lets allow Lake County political hacks to collect 80 million in income taxes so they can return less than half for property tax relief and squander the rest for whatever hair brained idea they may have. I don't think so! Show me where they are cutting the cost of government before they reach for my pocket. Most of these idiots will be unemployed soon if the voters turn out to voice their opinions in May/November anyway! "

They just don't get it wrote on Feb 20, 2008 8:32 AM:

" We HAVE to vote these senators out of office as soon as we can. They simply don't understand what it means to cut back. STOP SPENDING OUR MONEY!! "

Bex wrote on Feb 20, 2008 5:56 AM:

" Schools will loose 170 million dollars?! Lets just keep our children at home and not educate them. Then we can save more money!!!

Have we already given up on our future...CHILDREN?! "

Back to story 10 comment(s)

Post a comment Once your comments are approved, they will appear here.

Marketplace

Sections

Services

Other Publications

Search