Hobart family claims police abuse

Font Size:

BY DEBORAH LAVERTY
dlaverty@nwitimes.com
219.762.1397, ext. 2223 | Tuesday, February 26, 2008 | (287 comment(s))

NWI Photo Store

HOBART | Candace Olig couldn't hold back the tears Monday as her lawyers played a videotape they say provides visual proof of her family's accusations of police abuse. Watch the surveillance video (Edited for brevity).

The 32-minute videotape, taken on the night of Aug. 30 in the Oligs' front yard, shows police arriving at the home in response to a call by the Oligs, who reported a disturbance in their neighborhood involving a speeding car. In moments, the scene turns violent.

Words are exchanged before a police officer enters the Oligs' front yard and then is seen throwing a punch that knocks Candace Olig to the ground. As a struggle ensues involving other officers and family members, the same officer is seen in the video pointing his gun at her.

Other family members, including husband James Olig, 46, and sons David, 21, and Brian, 18, can be seen in the videotape being grabbed, wrestled to the ground and handcuffed by police. The Oligs' younger children are seen on the video watching the scene from the front porch.

The incident, which was videotaped on the Oligs' home security system, is the basis of a tort claim notice filed last week by Dyer lawyers Ronald F. Layer and Michael Babcock.

The claim is a prerequisite for a lawsuit alleging police abuse and unnecessary use of force that will be filed within a 90-day period, Layer said Monday during a news conference at his law firm.

Deputy Police Chief Jeff White and Lt. Steve Houck, the department's spokesman, referred all questions on the case to Hobart City Attorney John Bushemi.

Bushemi, who acknowledged receiving a copy of the claim on Wednesday, said Monday the incident is being investigated.

Mayor Brian Snedecor, a former Hobart police chief who was a detective sergeant at the time of the incident, confirmed the investigation.

Layer said three police officers, Paul Oliver, Mark Mokris and David Burney, responded to the complaint shortly after 10 p.m. that night, initially speaking to the four family members, who were in the front yard of their house in the 300 block of North Wilson Street.

"The incident was caught on security video. We looked at it long and hard, and we still felt what we saw was abuse and unnecessary use of force," Layer said.

All four Oligs were arrested and face pending charges that include disorderly conduct, resisting law enforcement and battery on law enforcement, he said. Family members had no prior criminal arrests, Layer and the family members said.

Babcock said the Oligs were standing in their front yard, and were talking to police, who remained on the opposite side of the front-yard fence.

He said the two sides exchanged information about the speeding vehicle disturbance.

"But it's obvious to them the officers have no interest in what they are saying," Babcock said.

It is after the Oligs tell police that they will take the matter up with the mayor that James Olig can be seen in the video heading with his family back to their house, Babcock said.

"We're done here," James Olig reportedly told police.

Candace Olig said it was then that Oliver followed the family inside the fence and called her a "fat ass."

She said she didn't respond to the police taunt but she was punched by Oliver, who later pointed his gun at her before taking her into custody.

Candace Olig, who suffered head injuries, was the only one of the four who sought medical assistance, Babcock said.

As seen on tape

Events of Aug. 30 as seen in the family's home surveillance video and according to their attorneys, Ronald Layer and Michael Babcock:

* Olig family calls Hobart police to their home, in the 300 block of North Wilson Street, shortly after 10 p.m. in regard to a speeding car disturbance in their neighborhood.

* Three police officers arrive and begin discussing the disturbance issue with Candace and James Olig and their sons David and Brian, all of whom were standing in their yard.

* The verbal discussion ends, say the Oligs, because police don't seem interested.

* James Olig tells police he'll take up the issue with the mayor and he attempts to usher his wife and two sons back to their house.

* Officer Paul Oliver is seen walking inside the family's fence, entering the yard and saying something to Candace Olig with the other two officers, Mark Mokris and David Burney, also entering the yard.

* Oliver is seen punching Candace Olig, knocking her to the ground. One of her sons can be seen attempting to protect his mother before Oliver takes him down too and then points a gun at Candace Olig.

* The other two officers can be seen subduing, then handcuffing James Olig and the couple's other son.

Back to story 287 comment(s)

Please note: Comments from readers will be screened and may not be posted immediately. If you don't see your comment perhaps:

It wasn't clear, concise or focused on the topic in the story.
It was a personal attack, vulgar, explicit or degrading, used actual or implied profanity or contained potentially libelous statements.
It accused someone of being guilty of a crime.
It promoted violence or illegal acts.
It contained telephone numbers or street addresses, or e-mail addresses and links to Web sites other than nwi.com or government agencies.

In no way do these comments represent the views of The Times or Lee Enterprises.

Passionate views, pointed criticism and critical thinking are welcome. Name-calling, crude and profane language and personal abuse are not welcome.

Reader comments will not be edited - they will be approved or declined. They may be used in the print edition of the newspaper.

If you feel a posted comment has violated these guidelines, please email our New Media team the commenter's name, the comment and a link to the article.

For more information please read our Terms of Service.

Hobart Resident wrote on Jun 7, 2008 9:43 PM:

" Maybe the girl that nearly killed the other girl in hobart this week figured if these kinds of actions are ok for the hobart police department then violence must be the best way to solve problems with our hobart teenagers!!!!!some of these comments are disturbing.police officers are supposed to protect there community,not beat them up!!!! "

American Patriot wrote on Mar 6, 2008 6:46 PM:

" There are many fine Police Officers out there, unfortunately, the people who did this to the Oligs don't count among them.

"

Question wrote on Mar 5, 2008 9:27 AM:

" Do these cops go by any Use of Force Model or is everything they do by there own judgment?

"

To: Look at the evidence wrote on Mar 4, 2008 10:49 PM:

" Obviously you didn't look at the evidence very closely?

1) Mother jerks arm away from husband,steps toward officer then back and yells at officer while using hand jestures. (could be perceived by officers as threatening?)

2) One officer enters yard to break up fight between mother and son. Officer pulls mother away.

3) Family members head towards officer, which brings other two (not three) officers into yard to seperate family.

4)How can you be sure mother was punched, can't see the actual contact because son is in line of view?

5)Look closely at officers feet just before the supposed "punch". Feet are in a position to push not punch.

6)I can see the officers percieving mother as a threat because look how she singles out and goes after that one officer, none of the other officers, at least three times.

I bet when the police reports are made public, the video will make more sense as to why this situation got so out of hand. The FACT is, we only know what the Oligs have told us. "

Mike wrote on Mar 4, 2008 8:19 PM:

" I'm not from Illinois but I recently read about this. I guess I just can't understand how something like this could be excuseable.

The only thing to say is that there should be a full investigation. "

NWI RES wrote on Mar 4, 2008 4:25 PM:

" This family is a joke!!! It looks like they were fighting with each other and the cops had to break it up. Let me guess all you people on here if the cops wouldn't have stepped in and broke them up it would be there fault too. If everyone acted the way they should cops wouldn't have to act the way they do. I've never been in a situation like this before and never plan on it. Why??? Because I know how to act. "

to: JOHN AGAIN wrote on Mar 4, 2008 11:45 AM:

" Dear John, if you read my comment of 02/27/08 @3:32pm you will realize the type of person i believe (and have observed in the past) a police officer should be, and how incidents should be handled. heck, i would have thrown in a few swear words about the "speeders" to make the O's understand i DO, in fact, side with them. our family does have police/military members who are very professional, and are not the power hungry, egotistical type spoken of here by many. unfortunately, these type DO exist, but they do not outnumber the professional-type officers. i do agree that court related issues for an officer DO exist, BUT after searching I FIND A NUMBER OF INCIDENTS that are UNUSUAL and should have been highlighted by the media. to me they are VERY SERIOUS in nature, and have been ignored - protected you might say. i don't understand your reasoning as to vindication? the lawyers who have taken this case must perceive differently. "

To: Who becomes a Cop wrote on Mar 4, 2008 10:20 AM:

" You are correct (kind of) about who becomes a cop. I used to be a cop and it made me sick how some of them made themselves out to be heroes. All they ever do is hang around with each other and talk about police work and the calls they responded to. When you get a sorry group like this together (usually the ones who go to FOP meetings all of the time) there is trouble both for the agency and the citizens/victims that they believe they are saving. When they do something stupid like this, they claim that their life was in jeopardy or they just want to go home at the end of the shift. The good news is the majority of cops are good people and don't respond to the people they serve like this. "

Who becomes a Cop wrote on Mar 4, 2008 7:39 AM:

" No dought policemen have a very difficult and underpaid job. What kind of person(s) takes on this profession? I do believe they are the unpopular and alwayes looking for attention (kids) back when in school. The type of people who strive to tell others what to do. I think most have ego problems. "

Dan Blankenship wrote on Mar 3, 2008 11:04 PM:

" What kind of police officer punches a woman in the face cause she gets smart with him? This is the most clear example of police brutality I have ever seen.

I hope the Oligs' when their case, and I hope the police officer that thought he was a tough guy for punching a woman is fired.

"

John Again wrote on Mar 3, 2008 10:10 PM:

" You just searched Indiana Officers? There is nothing unique to Indiana Officers when compared with any other state. Do you really think every lawsuit involving a police officer should get printed in the local newspaper? They are a dime a dozen. A lawsuit to a police officer is just part of the job; nothing special and certainly nothing to be concerned about. They are a source of overtime just like any other duty-related court appearance. The fact is it is VERY rare a police officer gets held PERSONALLY responsible for any damages. If this were the case it would sure be difficult to get people to do the job in the first place. These Hobart will be vindicated in the end - rest assured. "

Milly wrote on Mar 3, 2008 6:23 PM:

" After watching the video again, it is clear that this family had an altercation with each other and the police entered the grounds to stop the fight. Then everything blew up because the mom couldn't keep her nose out of it. I hope this family does not win any money for this. They are clearly at fault. "

to john 02/28/08 @ 9:39 pm wrote on Mar 3, 2008 5:02 AM:

" "Come to think of it" I started searching/googling local Indiana police departments and officer's names listed on their websites, and voila LOTS OF OVERTIME, john, you are right! VERY SCARY . . . wonder why more DON'T MAKE PRINT? Where's the media? Thanks for your comment, john, which prompted my search.

Kudos to the wonderful officers that DO their job professionly; it takes a certain type of person to put up with the situations that are presented on a daily basis, unfortunately, in my opinion, THIS SITUATION was not handled professionally! "

former hobart resident wrote on Mar 2, 2008 9:16 AM:

" as a former hobart resident, select police officers there have always seen themsleves as "above the law." there are several good police officers in hobart, but some of them have major issues. ive heard all the issues over the years of living there, now living in hammond, seems like the issue is in every town. the mayors of all nw indiana cities best need to look at how there police dept's. are run with a fine tooth comb. i though the the job of a police officer was "to serve and protect" but whom are they protecting???? "

Serve Who? Protect Who? wrote on Mar 1, 2008 11:54 PM:

" That police officer didn't look like he was going for anyone other than the woman. Didn't his mother ever teach him not to hit a woman? I don't care how she acted or what she said. If she really laid her hands on the officer first then she should have immediately been taken to the ground, handcuffed and arrested. Doesn't look like that's what happened. These police officers are the ones who took this job. So no matter what they deal with day-in day-out there is no excuse for this kind of behavior. IT WAS OUT OF LINE! "

Innocent Taxpayer wrote on Mar 1, 2008 8:28 PM:

" Looks like there is one popular video in Lake County within the last few days. Are you sure there is no audio? I bet there is. I'm glad the family decided to move forward. Mrs. Olig, may god walk next to you and your family trhu this awful and humiliating time. "

I'm not a cop, but... wrote on Mar 1, 2008 2:53 PM:

" ...she went at the cop, what did she expect to happen? "

TO: To: To To Chet & Police Officer wrote on Mar 1, 2008 12:49 PM:

" Did To Chet & Police Officer ruffle a feather? Why is it that some officers are so much more responsible and smarter than cops who have been around for ages? Must be in the drinking water down at the pd. To the officers who are AN ICON TO SOCIETY, thank you and keep up the awesome work. "

Proud Officer wrote on Mar 1, 2008 11:28 AM:

" thank you jon at least someone understand what life is like as a police officer "

wow wrote on Mar 1, 2008 8:34 AM:

" Looks like the family provoked the police into this situation knowing the video was on. WHAT A WAY TO MAKE A BUCK. I didn't see any police brutality on that tape. "

SHE WAS NOT PUNCHED wrote on Feb 29, 2008 2:15 PM:

" Look closely, she was NOT punched. I can not believe no one can see that. She grabbed the officers arm and he push her away pushing her elbow and she fell over. Twice he PUSHED her away when she tried to interfer. LOOK CLOSELY, IT IS SO CLEAR. Good Job Officers she deserve to go to jail. "

Bottom Line wrote on Feb 29, 2008 11:58 AM:

" Police arrive to a calm situation, and fail to keep it that way. As a former Federal Law Enforcement official the video shows mistake after mistake by the three officers. Seperate the individuals and control the scene pops in my head as a major mistake which ultimately led to this disturbance. Just poor police work thats the botom line. "

G Davis wrote on Feb 29, 2008 10:58 AM:

" Why would you call the police at all? all you are doing is bothering them from hiding waiting for somebody not wearing a seatbelt.Then if they do come you can always tell that they don't want to be bothered with it!And i'm tired of hearing this fallecy that they put their life on the line everyday!Ya Right.Go become a Army Pathfinder do 2 combat tours and make it back alive then tell me about it! "

look at the evidence wrote on Feb 29, 2008 9:12 AM:

" John wrote on Feb 28, 2008 9:39 PM:
John: did you watch the video? I have to laugh when you say this family of aggressors was not listening to police. First of all there is no sound so you didn't hear a darn thing and second I believe it was the police that came into the yard from the other side of the fence not the other way around. If as you say the family were the sggresors this would have taken place in the street? "

Support The Police wrote on Feb 29, 2008 9:08 AM:

" I support the police. When you are talking to an officer FOR ANY REASON, you don't clentch your fists and act stupid and jumping around like a fool. I feel bad for police officers because I can't even imagine the goof balls they have to meet up with on a daily basis. "

look at the evidence wrote on Feb 29, 2008 9:03 AM:

" What do we know ?

1. This family called the police to report about some speeders on their street.

2. This family has a surveillance camera pointed at their front yard and street.

3. The camera shows video of an incident showing a family in their front yard behind a fence talking with police on the other side of the fence.

4. The video shows police entering the yard through a gate and a confrontation takes place, we see an officer strike a woman in the face with his fist and later draw his weapon and point it at the unarmed women.

What we are not sure of.

1. What was said

2. Why did the women appear to be upset? Was it because she was complaining about the speeders and she didn’t feel the police were listening?

3. Why the officer went into the front yard and pursued this family and then punched this women. Did he feel threatened and feared for his life even with the backup and support from the 3 other officers who were present.

"

Wow wrote on Feb 29, 2008 8:43 AM:

" I have four friends who are police officers. Two are on SWAT teams. They were suprised to see the cop hit the woman like he did. But then they could not believe the Hobart cop pull his gun on the woman. In addition, they cannot believe that officer is still on the street. The officer should be sitting behind a desk until the investigation is completed. The only time you use your weapon is in a last resort, deadly situation. That did not look like a deadly/dangerous situation for the officer. The whole thing is an unfortunate situation that could have went really bad. "

TO: Greg Guzman wrote on Feb 29, 2008 8:30 AM:

" Greg maybe you live in a city with no crime,without kids that like being pranksters if so please tell me where that that is so we can all move there. I live in a ncie neighborhood but even here we have the occasional crime, the occasional break in and lately people preying on senior citizens, I have 6 cameras outside of my house, three for otusdie doors, 2 between houses and 1 pinting to the street becuase you never know. it is a sad part of life but unfortunetly it has gotten to the point where we have to be mroe vigilant. I honestly don't think this family was setting up the police, most experienced police officers would have arrested them without incident. "

yeahbaby wrote on Feb 29, 2008 8:13 AM:

" It looks to me like wife and husband are trying to move back into the house. The officer keeps stepping around to stop them. Even if the Olig's called the police names is that a reason to punch someone. There may be more to this. The video I saw shows the Hobart police losing control of the situation. Maybe they should of backed off and called in a supervisor. "

To The Cops wrote on Feb 29, 2008 7:55 AM:

" You're BUSTED! "

john wrote on Feb 29, 2008 2:13 AM:

" I have plans to leave East Chicago to move to Hobart with my family,but no thanks.............. "

I still don't get it wrote on Feb 28, 2008 11:52 PM:

" Why would a camera pointed at the street or anywhere be a set up? Are you saying the camera made the officer assault the woman?
And what is this stuff about her having mace? Wouldn't the family have been charged with that? I mean before the cops found out they were on video?
And did you see that the officer actually took 3 swings at the woman and not one at any of the male so-called aggressors? And did you notice how rough the cop was with the guy that held her down, helping him while one of the males was being handcuffed? He wasn't resisting. He was just standing there. And then when he had the woman handcuffed, he kept pulling her by the handcuffs back and forth making her lose her balance. Was that necessary?
We all appreciate cops and what they do every day. But, no one appreciates cops who can't control themselves.
"

Porter County Resident wrote on Feb 28, 2008 10:45 PM:

" To Tony : There's nothing wrong with these police officers wives being proud of their husbands or any wife for that matter . They have a dangerous job and yes I am well aware that alot of husbands do . But again there's nothing wrong with a Wife being proud of her Husband . "

John wrote on Feb 28, 2008 9:39 PM:

" This is the ugly face of what really happens in the life of a police officer on a regular basis. The general population just does not get to see it most of the time. Police work is ugly, often unsympathetic, rapidly evolving,and dangerous. Most of the general population has NO training or true insight into when a police officer has a RIGHT to use force. This video clearly shows a family of aggressors not listening to police and being forcibly detained. Punching a female in the face is an ugly sight, but not necessarily wrong. The female aggressor quickly learned SHE is not the one in charge and she WILL listen when being told what to do. Regards to the Hobart officers for being placed in a tough situation and having a successful resolution. The certain lawsuits and such are nothing to worry about - they are part of the job and happen to all officers at one point or another. They are actually a good source of overtime come to think of it! "

Tim S wrote on Feb 28, 2008 7:14 PM:

" Police are not supposed to have anger management problems. As a teacher I am not allowed to touch a student who is aggressive, but am to call for the police. They are not allowed to use force unless threatened with a weapon that can cause serious bodily harm (a series of escalation of restraint is to be used, starting with verbal authority.) I'd really like to hear the HPD side of this story, or as a society do we need to take a deep look at restraints being placed on police behavior. These are paid civil servants allowed to carry deadly weapons in defense of the civil society, not to defend their personal feelings. "

sherlock holmes wrote on Feb 28, 2008 7:14 PM:

" How can they sue the police. Aren't they innocent until proven guilty? Go ahead and jump the police. Anyone that can watch this video can tell that you have issues of your own with reality. How can you claim something when you know yourself you are wrong? There is absolutley no way you can convince me that you truly believe that the police are in the wrong. No sane individual could remotely view it that way. It is what it is. Sorry but welcome to the real world. "

Greg Guzman wrote on Feb 28, 2008 5:09 PM:

" Who calls the police *and* is FILMING the interaction? A set up possibly? Lack of sound makes it inconclusive for me to fully assess allegations of misconduct. "

tk wrote on Feb 28, 2008 4:46 PM:

" Wow Ive watched the video twice now and I can barely tell who is who. But yet everyone here who has no idea what happened either is quick to jump the gun and scream police brutality. Whatever happened this family provoked. "

donbad wrote on Feb 28, 2008 3:55 PM:

" Watch the video again and see the son who comes to the aid of his mother .Does he deserve to be arrested and tackled by the officer? Yes,the mother got in the way of the officer & maybe deserved what she had coming. The kid did nothing to offend or threaten the cop.Why did the cop tackle him next? This situation just got out of hand.Terrible for that family & the police dept. of Hobart. "

fishy wrote on Feb 28, 2008 3:08 PM:

" Why is this home security camera taping towards the street? Why is it not pointed at the front door or the driveway, where their cars are? "

Police Wife wrote on Feb 28, 2008 12:10 PM:

" TO: Tony
I completely understand where you are coming from and I am in no way justifying what this cop did, nor choosing a side. I am simply stating that people automatically choose to believe the citizen, though none of us were there to witness this chain of events in person. Though there is a tape, it is still very unclear what happened. I know there are law enforcement people whom act the way you are describing, however, I also know ther same people are not malicious enough to just go into a home a beat up a family. Everything is still very unclear "

zjlv wrote on Feb 28, 2008 11:55 AM:

" TO: Valpo Jovan
Bravo, finally some sense here. "

To Chet & Police Officer wrote on Feb 28, 2008 10:32 AM:

" Again, training and experience. "

oh you know wrote on Feb 28, 2008 9:58 AM:

" I just love all the negative comments claiming "they are just out to get money".. this is so typical of people to assume!

Hobart is so full of morons which is why we are moving away from here & the politics Hobart brings.
I grew up here and it's pretty sad to see how things have gotten.
There aren't any good neighbors anymore just those who love to complain about everything & anything. I miss the old days!
I won't be sorry to go!
"

TO: To Chet & Police Officer wrote on Feb 28, 2008 9:01 AM:

" Perhaps you should be the one that revisits the "force continuum. Here is a little refresher... It is generally noted that an officer NEED NOT progress through each level before reaching the final level of force. These progressions rest on the premise that officers should escalate and de-escalate their level of force in response to the subject's actions. The argument might be made that having four to five offenders approaching three officers would call for an escalation of the continuum. "

Tony wrote on Feb 28, 2008 8:57 AM:

" To the wives of all the cops who are writing in giving their two cents. Please get over the hero and what a great guy crap. While some of you might have a wonderful husband who happens to be a cop, I would honestly say a large majority of these cops got into this job becuase of the pwoer that comes with it. I have many friends who i make fun of on a regular basis becuase they are honest about why they are cops. I have ben told countless times that they became cops becuase they get to do whatever the heck they want. So cop wives, unless you are hiding under a rock please don't come on here with that pitiful crap about these guyds being great and heros and all that other bull. it's cops like these three that we have no respect for the true honest cops. and even most of them will still cover each other. sad but true. get over yourself "

To Chet & Police Officer wrote on Feb 28, 2008 7:28 AM:

" I guess the two of you need to be re-educated on the force continuum. Again, if she was under arrest and resisting the next logical step is not a strike to the face. What happened to the control moves and less than lethal weapons. If that was mace then he obviously had them. If it was a gun then he escalated to the highest level and put everyone's life in harms way. He went from a two to a five(verbal to striking blows) just because she put her hands on him? Come on. What academy did you go to? I hope that all of the cops in supervisory positions are reading this because with untrained cops like this on the streets, your bank accounts are in jeopardy too. Supervisors can be held liable because the officers the command lack training.

Chet I don't know if you are a cop but the person who claims to be an officer is a sorry excuse. You make it bad for the real police(like me). You should go to training and request that you receive more instructions or resign before you hurt someone or yourself. "

Police wife wrote on Feb 28, 2008 7:18 AM:

" This is a whole lot of nonsense in the comments I am reading depicting these police officers as violent and incredulous. None of us were there to see this confrontation nor have any idea events that happened prior to this video, as its only a few minutes long. As a policemans wife (and no, not to one from Hobart), I see what these men and women have to struggle with day in and day out. It enrages me to know that so many people don't appreciate everything they do for us. They too have wives, or husbands, and children to come home to, though they don't exactly have a comfy desk job. They put their lives on the line to make sure your CHILDREN, spouses, parents, and siblings have a better world to live in. Its funny how you could rant and rave about a person driving significantly over the speed limit, whom then killed a mother taking her children to school, but as soon as you are the one speeding, its the cops fault for pulling you over before a devistating thing like that happens. "

Valpo Jovan wrote on Feb 28, 2008 1:45 AM:

" As a former Police Officer, I have read these editorials,laughed and applauded the ignorance and intelligence of John Q Public. The "minority" will look for ALL INFORMATION and EVIDENCE and try and formulate an educated opinion. The "majority" it appears, will serve as judge and jury based on what few facts it is presented. Lets not ask for the whole video and facts at hand, lets decide on a fraction of same!!! I know these men and I pray that the investigative contingent gather all the evidence before claiming themselves Judge & Jury on minimal media related information. These days, many would rather find fault at no cost, then to seek the truth for it's true value. Heaven help those whom put their life,property & Self Respect on the line, so that others may rest easy at night. GOD Bless Law Enforcement !!!! "

TO: A Bit of Education wrote on Feb 27, 2008 10:26 PM:

" AMEN!!! "

go cops go wrote on Feb 27, 2008 9:51 PM:

" that family was out of control. and they just so happen to have a camera pointed right where the incodent happen and where was the car that kept driving by. i support the cops all the way. "

RE; Re: Voice of reason wrote on Feb 27, 2008 8:24 PM:

" To the person whom thought I had commented on some moilestation issue. I had not.

Actually, I just adopted the handle of VOR (voice of reason), because I was hoping that I could get the debate back to facts. Facts like, you can not stike someone, just for calling you a name. That is the law, and police officers are not above it.

Terms like provocation and probable cause, are rules for the police not tools for exercising revenge for disrespect. In other words, no matter what that family said, or how unattractive they are to watch, the actions of the police, as shown in the portions of the tape seen, are unacceptable.

The officers should be punished for abuse of power, but that does not mean the family deserves riches.

"

Walk the line wrote on Feb 27, 2008 7:50 PM:

" Being married to a policeman, it is quite difficult to read this.My husband's goal every day as he goes to work is to come home to his family. Regardless of whether or not, these officers were out of line is not for us to judge. We have to remember that we are all human, none of us are perfect. Police officers have a hard job,but the ones who really have it hard are the families of police officers. The schedule is rough and not knowing on a daily basis if your spouse will come home runs a toll on you. So keep that in mine when writing all of these negative posts. Instead of bad-mouthing HPD, we should be looking at ways to build better communication between the police and the community. I am proud of my husband and I thank all police officers who put their lives on the line every day. This is one incident where you may not think the officers did their job correctly, but think about how often they have saved a life or took real criminals off of the street. "

Catherine wrote on Feb 27, 2008 7:26 PM:

" My thoughts and prayers go out to the Olgin family. I'm so sorry. You called the police thinking you would get help. One news program reported your 8 year old son called 911 at the time this happened. As taxpayers, and residents of Hobart 18 years you were paying those officers salaries. I believe the truth will come out because of the security camera video taping. I'm going out and installing a security camera.
"

Porter County Resident wrote on Feb 27, 2008 7:03 PM:

" Re: Police Officer : Amen , I appreciate you and your fellow officers putting your life on the line daily for me . God Bless all of you and keep you safe . "

andy taylor wrote on Feb 27, 2008 6:29 PM:

" In this law suit crazed country we live in these three cops are unemployable.
You can't just keep rasing taxes to cover the excesses of the public servants.
Cities all over the U.S. are using CCTV to increase shrinking revenues, is anyone here supprised that events like this happen?
What's good for the goose will certainly be capitalized on by the gander.
"

Don Dodge wrote on Feb 27, 2008 6:22 PM:

" I admit not knowing a lot about police procedures. But I do know right from wrong. I also know, as do millions, that police abusing their authority, police corruption, and police twisting the stories of a situation happens every day. The simple fact that they get away with behavior that would get most people arrested is what angers people. "

LM wrote on Feb 27, 2008 5:55 PM:

" side note had a great question....where IS the video of the car speeding down the street? "

DUH Factor wrote on Feb 27, 2008 5:10 PM:

" The officer came into the yard because the mother and one of her boys aggressed each other. The officer didn't invade thier space he saw a crime take place. Candace then charged at the officer. Watch the officer back away to prevent an altercation. You people have eyes...use them! let me know what else you can't seem to figure out...I'll help...I promise "

Police Officer wrote on Feb 27, 2008 4:40 PM:

" I am a Police Officer and if someone touchs me or makes an aggresive move towards me it would be the same reaction. You people have no idea how a simple person moving towards you can take your life or injure you. Wake up people if you make threats or touch an Officer you should go to jail and face your actions. Not one of you put your life in danger like the Police do. If you have such a problem with the Police then dont call them call the crack heads or pot heads to save your butt when your in trouble. "

Tim S wrote on Feb 27, 2008 4:22 PM:

" This is the most commented on article I have seen. Most disturbing are the people who blame the Olig's. The family has no weapon's. The police responded to a call from the family/ Police are not allowed to respond to verbal provocation from non-offending citizens and the Oleg's had apparently not committed a crime. If the police felt the call was not justified they have the option of ticketing the false call. There's no mention of the police reporting a dangerous incident to a dispatcher. Even if you are drunk but on your own property and causing no public nuisance or danger, should the police be allowed to enter your gated property and physically restrain you because of verbal provocation made in retreat. "

More details wrote on Feb 27, 2008 4:03 PM:

" "Police reports state James and Candace Olig verbally abused the officers, stating that police wouldn’t do anything about their complaints. James Olig became so abusive, the report states, Oliver told him he was under arrest.

On video, Olig throws up his hands in disgust and begins leading his wife and sons back toward the house. Oliver walks through the fence gate to follow Olig— the Oligs claim Oliver called Candace a “fat @zz” as she apparently came between him and James.

His report does not describe the shove or blow that sends the 41-year-old woman sprawling onto the lawn, touching off a melee in the front yard, which is described in detail. It does mention David losing his balance and knocking his mother over.

At one point, Burney threw Brian to the ground with a hip-toss move, as Mokris and Oliver struggled to subdue James and David. Oliver pulled out his gun and pointed it at Candace when she walked toward him and Mokris as they tried to cuff David. "

"

chet wrote on Feb 27, 2008 4:01 PM:

" To the two Hey Chets: both of you are idiots....You actually think that the police just show up and BEAT UP on people. YOU PEOPLE want it all: criminals behind bars, your property protected, speeders stopped which all is done courtesy of a police crystal ball and magic carpet. Such ignorance. Like I said....strap on a vest and do the job. Learn police procedures like force continuum and one plus one theory. "

chester wrote on Feb 27, 2008 3:57 PM:

" To the Yo Chester....so you bought pot from a cop....congratulations...you are a real original. Like I said typical. And I never said I condone such behavior. But all of you seem to be such experts and you were not there. Like I said..if you don't do the job..you don't have a clue. You just can't admit it. As a closing remark...what if you have a problem and you don't call the police. Handle it yourself/ "

Ex-Resident wrote on Feb 27, 2008 3:51 PM:

" To: Angry Hammond Resident
Your attitude is one good reason to leave Hammond. You people over there are so used to violence, that you find ways to justify it. I got my family out of Hammond, and never regretted it. "

WAIT A MINUTE!!! wrote on Feb 27, 2008 3:38 PM:

" Were we all there people? NO!! The video to me, shows that she was the one that took a menacing step forward and she had to be held back...it's plain as anything on the video. We can't hear what was said, but I bet it was rude and she could have threatened the officer's life for all we know. The newspapers don't always print everything, because it needs to be brought up in trial first. SHE MADE THE FIRST MOVE!!! And honestly....why do they have video camera surveilance around their home? That's weird, unless they wanted to catch something that would make them newsworthy!!! "

if i were the police officers in this case ... wrote on Feb 27, 2008 3:32 PM:

" i would have politely agreed with the family that a vehicle traveling at a high rate of speed is very dangerous. secondly i would request the family keep a log (date, time, and vehicle(s)) and report the logged info to me, as it would be helpful in patrol efforts. i would further explain that if a pattern was established that i could watch the area at a specific time or day, and ticket the offender. i would have given them my card, let them know that this incident would be reported, that they are a vital part of the community as police cannot be everywhere, and that their help would be greatly appreciated. good night - thank you for bringing this to our attention.

even if someone is screaming from the get go, there are ways to calm them down, and make them understand that you (the police officer) are on the same side as they are. work together!

people are TOO hyper nowadays! it's the instant gratification century!

"

Stewie wrote on Feb 27, 2008 3:15 PM:

" Watch the video a couple of times and you will see as I did,

She started it! "

Hammond Resident wrote on Feb 27, 2008 3:08 PM:

" I hope Police Officers around this area are reading these comments. I hope all you Officers see how unappreciated you are and how you are being labeled and stereotyped because of the actions of a few. This is a shame because there are several good professional Police Officers out there. Besides, all the good stories involving Police don't make the news. "

DUH Factor wrote on Feb 27, 2008 2:56 PM:

None wrote on Feb 27, 2008 2:50 PM:

" This is not the first incident I heard about, they had my son on the ground on Wisconsin smashing his face into the gravel. Nice Job HPD. I am glad someone finally got it on tape, what a bunch of non professional jerks "

Amazing! wrote on Feb 27, 2008 2:41 PM:

" All this video of wrongdoing and I'm having trouble identifying George Van Til. Is he directing this video? "

GVT wrote on Feb 27, 2008 2:27 PM:

" Somewhere George Van Til is waiting for a call on how to spin this into saving the tax payers money. "

Yo Chester wrote on Feb 27, 2008 2:26 PM:

" I would venture to guess there are many, many police officers that would not pass a drug test either. In fact, I would bet on it. In my younger days I bought pot from a cop, many times. My friends and I used used to joke about it, how we got the best weed from a cop. True story and I lived in Hobart back then, coincidence? "

Hey Chet wrote on Feb 27, 2008 2:21 PM:

" You sound like you have strapped on a vest (bullet proof) and have beat the snot out of a few desperado women in night gowns too. No wonder you feel the need to travel in packs and pick on Joe or Jane tax payer. Real criminals obviously scare the dickens out of you! "

Hey chet wrote on Feb 27, 2008 2:12 PM:

" Some of us did or still do strap on a vest. Oliver was out of line. Even if the lady was under arrest, that is not how we do it. If you are a cop and you think this behavior is appropriate then you need to find another profession Maybe WWE or Extreme Fighting. "

Not surprised wrote on Feb 27, 2008 2:11 PM:

" There is no respect anywhere these days. Looking at this video several times, it does seem to me she hit/pushed the officer first. Whatever family member is standing (in perfect position) by them seems to block some of what takes place. Remember people, he is a son, husband, father, brother, friend and most importantly a human being!! To many out there really have authority issues to quickly jump all over the police in such a hateful manner. Seems the way of the world, sue and get rich quick while others pay and you take no resposibility for anything. It is just sad how free people are with hateful comments. The media is very much to blame for alot of this. And lawyers who have to "advertise" their case with news conferences! Officer Oliver and the other officers,I will be behind you no matter what the media makes of this! I know you are a good cop on a good police force and good person, and hopefully more will be less eager to judge or listen to the hype the lawyers and media want to spew about Hobart and force. "

Chester wrote on Feb 27, 2008 1:35 PM:

" It is amazing. Anytime a police officer "supposedly" does anything wrong it means the job and some big settlement. That's always the solution. I think some of you who have jobs need to be drug tested. I wonder how many would pass. And I know, what's that got to do with it? My response....typical. "

chet wrote on Feb 27, 2008 1:25 PM:

" YOU PEOPLE: I think some of you should try being a cop for a while. And I don't mean an hour or two. Go strap on a vest (that's bullet proof) and patrol some streets on a midnight shift. People who don't do the job don't have a clue. Pretty easy to watch a video and act like you know everything about the law, defensive tactics, and what officers can legally do. "

COPS wrote on Feb 27, 2008 1:12 PM:

" Unfortunately, there are a lot of idiots, like Oliver, that have absolutely no business wearing a badge. They, like Oliver and his pals on the video, are on power trips and think they are superior to any judge/jury and it is their right to pass sentence on the rest of us. It does not matter what the woman, or her family, may have said that angered these goons. If you do not earn respect you won't get respect and its actions like this that makes most people fear and dislike the police. I hope all those creeps end up paying a huge price for their indiscretions. "

Resident wrote on Feb 27, 2008 1:08 PM:

" This is completely inexcusable and I have not followed this case closely but based on that video I sure hope that the City of Hobart fires that Oliver. It is so incredibly sad to see what police officers think they can getaway with. That is great that the Olig’s happened to have a security camera setup to catch this idiot. This comes down to the integrity of the city and it is clear that they have made a couple of other poor selections while hiring police officers. I am sure that there have been many good officers but along with that come the bad. So hopefully Hobart will make the right decision. "

disgraced wrote on Feb 27, 2008 1:08 PM:

" The officers involved in this incident should be fired! Instead of diffusing the situation, they stood there and argued with the people for quite some time, then got physical. It seems the law was looking to start the fight.I'm just glad I don't live in Hobart. "

you should watch it wrote on Feb 27, 2008 12:57 PM:

" dont go just by the times description, watch it for yourself. the description leaves alot out, and outright says the opposite of the video in some places. i suspect the description really came from the complaint filed rather than the video.

btw, i find it entirely possible that the cops were already trying to place her under arrest when she tried to "walk away." this means they would have to get in front of her, as you see in the video. she DID attack them first. WATCH THE VIDEO! "

Wendy Weinbaum wrote on Feb 27, 2008 12:54 PM:

" What CROOKED Cops!

But, as a Jewess in the US, I have NEWS for all liberals. American wasn't won with a registered gun! And criminals on EITHER side of the law are stopped by the presence of FIREARMS, not by talk. That is why all REAL Americans put our 2nd Amendment FIRST! "

nwa wrote on Feb 27, 2008 12:25 PM:

" ice cube was right!!!!!!! "

My Hobart PD Encounter wrote on Feb 27, 2008 12:22 PM:

" My experience with the Hobart PD in Jul-06:

They knowingly allowed an East Chicago Cop to destroy evidence in their possession at their Station, failed to note the destruction in a report and denied knowledge of the incident.

They took a complaint from an East Chicago PD Cop who I could prove was lying if they would have taken 15 minutes to investigate the ECPD Cop's complaint, but they would not take my complaint for assault and attempted battery by him because I was not a cop.

They knowingly allowed a subpoenaed video of a booking showing the destruction of evidence to be overwritten and thus destroyed.

They failed to investigate an incident in their jurisdiction that involved an East Chicago Cop.

They were insolent with me when I tried to recover my property, and they delayed returning it for 3+ hours while I waited.

The HPD and Mayor told me all of the above were withing their normal Police Department Procedures. "

John E. Law wrote on Feb 27, 2008 12:02 PM:

" I hope these cops get what they deserve!
The police for the most part think they are GOD and can do whatever they want! When you need saomething there never around but god forbid you don't wear your seatbelt!! Cops for the most part are guys that got picked on in highscool and want to ruin other peoples lives!! What a JOKE!! "

Valparaiso resident wrote on Feb 27, 2008 11:53 AM:

" This video is disturbing as are some of the comments being posted about it. Anyone who thinks these things doesn't happen is seriously naive. There are bad cops in every county and every town in NW Indiana. These few give the good ones a bad name and make it even harder for them to do their jobs. We need to be more vigilent and aware of what is going on and individual officers need to make sure that their fellow officers who are crossing that line are stopped. "

SEE WHAT HAPPENS wrote on Feb 27, 2008 11:53 AM:

" This is what happens when a bar room bouncer is offered a job as a law enforcement professional.

I hope you are fired Oliver. I only hope tax payers do not have to pay for your legal defense. It should come out of your own pocket. "

Chris wrote on Feb 27, 2008 11:50 AM:

" Cant believe all of these people sticking up for the Hobart Police, if someone hit my mom or wife like that, no matter what she said, they would have to shoot me. "

Tony wrote on Feb 27, 2008 11:41 AM:

" To the morons on here who question why they would have a camera taping their front yard, thinking that it might be a set-up, I have a simple answer, cause the cops are out acting like criminals instead of protecting their town. I live in a nice neighborhood but I also have cameras around my house, with crime rising all over the place, you have to care for your own. I would rather spend money and install cameras than later regret not having done it. I want to be able to protect my family as well as my house becuase you can no longer count on the police to be there to protect you. i would suggest everyone isntall at least 2 cameras outside of thier home. "

resident wrote on Feb 27, 2008 11:30 AM:

" this is crazy!!!!! the police are here to serve and protect. if we can't call the police for help then who can we call? Obiviously no one! that officer needs to be fired, pay restitution, and sent to jail. Let him get beaten on in jail. I'm sure the inmates will have fun with him. He is the type of man that was picked/beaten up on as a kid and grew up wanting to be a cop and now thinks he's above the law. He's probably beats on his wife too!!!
Get rid of him!!!!!!
"

Float Like a Butterfly wrote on Feb 27, 2008 11:27 AM:

" Officer Oliver, you must work out. You handle yourself well against a much smaller woman. Obviously, you're a tuff guy! "

DUH Factor wrote on Feb 27, 2008 11:07 AM:

G Davis wrote on Feb 27, 2008 11:07 AM:

" American Gestapo 2008,War on Americans! somewhere along the line these wanna be heros are just blowin off steam because they missed the big one,Who wants to be riding around giving out tickets to people not wearing their seatbelt? somewhere along the line Police officers turned into storm troopers that don't look for the real battle because of what they might find so it's easier to beat up on women and drunks than look for real criminals with real guns! That could be dangerous. They are just practicing for when the boogie man from Iran comes here and they will be front line defense! "Your" President said it himself. "

DISGRACEFUL wrote on Feb 27, 2008 11:01 AM:

" The mayor and the chief of police in Hobart must be so proud of the criminals wearing the badges. What a disgrace to honest, GOOD, policemen and women everywhere. I hope the family gets rewarded a hefty sum for what Wyatt Earp did that evening. Maybe this can be used as a training video fro how not to handle a situation? "

RE: Voice of reason wrote on Feb 27, 2008 10:45 AM:

" Hey voice: arent you the one who said in an October article about a molester who should not be punished for his actions because it was a one time incident. How did listening work for you, i will tell you how - 10YEARS in prison. You were saying you cant get someone to grow up or be better by violence so why should any of these people be punished and not a molester. Abuse is abuse no matter who it is by. "

Resident wrote on Feb 27, 2008 10:39 AM:

" If this was a staged video, Officer Oliver must have been involved in the planning because he sure played his role well. "

30 year Hobart resident wrote on Feb 27, 2008 10:19 AM:

" I am a long time Hobart resident which has much pride in our community and people in it but what is wrong with the Hobart Police officers today? We do have very good police officers but it appears a select few are abusing their powers lately.

Case in point:

1. Hobart police officer pulls gun on person while off duty.
2. Hobart police officer hits child in face with water balloon during parade.

And now this? "

arthur wrote on Feb 27, 2008 9:50 AM:

" I can't imagine anything the people could have done to provoke that kind of reaction from the police. Is that police procedure...to run after someone who is walking away and clock them? And to draw a weapon...threatening citizens, no matter how obnoxious, with deadly force?
Forget, the tort action, these officers need to be in criminal court right away and get a verdict one way or the other. And the supervisors who let these idiot out on the street with the lack of training and wrong temperment should be in trouble too. "

Gary wrote on Feb 27, 2008 9:50 AM:

" American Gestapo.

Hopefully the family will buy something really nice with the settlement check they receive.

Is it any wonder deaths of police officers are at an all time high...? "

ignorant people wrote on Feb 27, 2008 9:47 AM:

" to blind to see the facts... i cant wait till u need an officer and they dont show up... ohh and go save a kitten out of a tree or something "

moretothestory wrote on Feb 27, 2008 9:40 AM:

" COME ON- what a setup. The whole family, trying to be good citizens, reporting a crime.. Just so happened the camera was on. How much money could they try to scam if we called police here, started problems to provoke them(knowing none of the comments can be heard) and use it against the city for a big settlement??? The cops shown in this tape were completely SET UP "

Susie G. wrote on Feb 27, 2008 9:37 AM:

" Mrs. Olig should have been more tactful when she wanted to talk to the cops, BUT regardless of how she and her were family acting like obnoxious loudmouths, police officers HAVE to be professional and NOT overstep their boundaries. Too many overzealous cops make a bad name to some who are professional and are able to pick their battles wisely. Cops have to deal with beligerent drunks on an everday basis and some are able to hold their cool. This woman maybe a classless bully, but this does not give the cops the right to assault an unarmed woman. They should have let her run her big mouth and make herself look like a fool, but instead they make the Hobart P.D. look foolish. Cops need to stop flexing their muscles and start being professional. And people like the Oligs need to learn manners and realize the world doesn't revolve around them. "

A Bit of Education wrote on Feb 27, 2008 9:31 AM:

" Silly people, there is no law on our books called Criminal Provocation. It might be a smart thing to talk crazy to a cop but it is not a crime. There was no crime committed until that officer struck a civilian. Since he was in a position of authority, he violated the whole family's civil rights He inflicted violence on a civilian under the color of law. He also inflicted emotional damage on the whole family by abusing that authority in front of them. I am sure that the feds will get involved in this as a criminal matter.

Look up the word provocation. You will clearly see that the action of that police officer is justification for the father and son to defend their loved one. Their criminal case will be thrown out. Professional police officers don't have the luxury of using provocation as a defense when dealing with unruly citizens even if it is a setup. Audio is not needed to see that he is wrong as two left gloves. "

Lauren wrote on Feb 27, 2008 9:18 AM:

" One more comment. Wht are these cops still on active duty?? THey should be on leave until the investigation is over.. Especially the idiot who pulled the gun. "

to media hounds wrote on Feb 27, 2008 9:15 AM:

" How would you like it if some cop pulled a gun on your husband or wife? Do youlive in hobart? I did for 5 years and it is a joke of a town. I lived in the west side (not to deep) and a cop lives down the street and his police car is there everyday in the driveway. I wonder if he ever works or just gets to sport a cop car. Hobart cops are jokes... "

To Schererville wrote on Feb 27, 2008 9:10 AM:

" You can't judge a book by it's cover. People might say the same about you.. "

Tom WIlliams wrote on Feb 27, 2008 8:45 AM:

" Even if this was staged, No One made the police offcier go after these people and hit anyone, let alone pull a gun.
Any judge will lecture anyone at anytime "No one made you do it"
So.... these police may have fallen into a trap. Looks like they did so......willingly "

Donald Trump wrote on Feb 27, 2008 8:07 AM:

" Your Fired! These are the words those police officers would here if i were the mayor, we as residents of this community have had enough of police thinking that they are above the law. Do you forget who pays your salary? We the taxpayers do, stop abusing your powers and start using your common sense, your actions just cost us more money...Thanks,as if i have a money tree i can just keep going to, UNREAL!! "

just sick.... wrote on Feb 27, 2008 7:53 AM:

" The police are taught to keep calm No MATTER WHAT! How can you justify punching or even arresting someone for being upset that yet another HOBART police officer refuses to take a report or do something about something so serious.
No matter what name calling you assume went on, went on this is not acceptable.
Do you know how many times we have called an officer to complain about a certain person calling in false reports on us, just because this person doesnt like us?
Do you know how frustrating it is when you are told to just shut up, that this person has every right to call them, even if it was 5 times a day.
Then tell us to stop harrassing the person!!! Even when we were not home when the alleged abuse took place! Hobart police have so many good officers and need to get these hotheads off the force NOW. "

Valpo Rez wrote on Feb 27, 2008 7:48 AM:

" P.S. DEAR INNOCENT TAXPAYER: PLEASE REPORT THIS!!! That is RIDICULOUS!!!! I hope The Times follows up with you because THAT is story worthy!!! "

Valpo Rez wrote on Feb 27, 2008 7:44 AM:

" I just can't believe the comments that are trying to justify what the police did. Normally, I would be sticking up for the police, but not in this case. Too, you all need to think about something: If that were YOUR mom that got punched, what would you do? And when you have a video security system at your house, it's a digital system that runs 24/7. I live in Valpo, but if I could afford it, you'd bet I'd get one too. Even if this woman is white trash, why does that justify him cracking her in the face? He wasn't trying to apprehend her. He flat our jacked her in the jaw. The cop that threw that first punch has no business being a public official. "

sidenote wrote on Feb 27, 2008 7:41 AM:

" Where is the video of the car speeding up and down the block? "

Know the Emotions wrote on Feb 27, 2008 7:32 AM:

" I've been in those situations before so I know the emotion of the cop. As a "professional" we are taught to have the calmer head. There is no excuse for punching a woman, man, boy or girl for insulting you. If she was under arrest, fine. If she touched him, fine. But to punch anyone like that is a crime. PERIOD. And for you cops and cop lovers out there who say people don't understand. I do. I did the job. I've fought men and women, boys and girls, young and old. I've fought them all. But I never punched one until they escalated the situation. When they escalated the situation, I finished it. Walking towards the house making insults is not an escalation. Especially when the call was about a traffic violation.
Threaten to call the supervisor or mayor. Go ahead because that is the next logical step. I'm up. Call thousands of times, I'll respond every time because that's my job.

That shield is more than a piece of metal. It is a symbol of protection. Not a symbol of get out of line and I'll punch you. "

Concerned citizen wrote on Feb 27, 2008 6:41 AM:

" Police Officers are under a great amount of stress, that is obvious. However, many, not all, but many, turn to ways of releasing their stress that are wrong. The criminals they are facing are not the same ones that were around even 10 years ago. The numbers are rising, and therefore the amount of officers on the street - however, this means more money being paid out in salaries which comes from taxpayer dollars. Perhaps if our local government were more frugal in how they spend the money in their coffers, this would help put more police officers on the streets.

Also, these officers need to learn how to manage their stress - and there are professionals for that. Looking at this situation, if the family was walking away from the police, the officers should have let it go instead of making the situation worse. It doesn't matter if a citizen is obnoxious.. if they aren't breaking the law, there is no reason to treat them that way.
Public officials - please do something about getting your police officers stress relief!!!!! "

BubbaLuv wrote on Feb 27, 2008 6:31 AM:

" A video camera on the front yard? H.P.D., you've been set up..... "

Milly wrote on Feb 27, 2008 5:43 AM:

" Without audio, I think it will be hard to determine exactly what happened that night. Do these people really own this house? You can not find any tax records in either Lake or Porter County. "

Dr. Who wrote on Feb 27, 2008 5:04 AM:

" Did the mother attacked the police over the fence? Are you watching the same video? Agreed the mother was restrained on HER side of the fence. The only chance for physical contact was when the officers entered the yard through the fence and smashed her face.

They should be suspended immediatly and prosecuted to the fullest extent. Better yet, both professionally and personally sued! "

Angry Hammond Resident wrote on Feb 27, 2008 4:59 AM:

" For those of you saying the female shouldn't have been hit.. I have advice for you and her. When you provoke a man to fight, be prepared to be hit like a man. So the fact that she tried to get on top of the police officer as he is trying to subdue her is not a relevant point? She is trying to interfere with an arrest. The police officer does not know if she has a knife, gun, or any other object that could be used to harm him. Before everyone judges the police, how about you put yourselves in their shoes? Oh, I forgot you are playing the pity role for stupid people that want to ignore the law. "

Resident wrote on Feb 27, 2008 4:31 AM:

" It doesn't matter what the woman said to the police officer, he should have shown restraint, which he didn't. He was not attacked, nor was he defending himself. He was the attacker. I hope the city has "deep pockets", because their going to need them. "

CHITOWN wrote on Feb 27, 2008 2:56 AM:

" I THINK THAT THEY WERE WRONG FOR WHAT THEY DID. NO MATTER WHAT THAT LADY SAID IF SHE EVEN SAID ANYTHING THEY DID NOTHING WRONG. THE STORY DOESN'T SAY SHE SAID F OFF OR DISRESPECTED THEM IN ANY WAY. IT SAYS SHE JUST SAID FORGET IT WE'LL TAKE IT UP WITH THE MAYOR. THIS IS SOMEONE WHO CAN MAYBE ENFORCE SOME LAWS ABOUT SPEEDING IN THE COMMUNITY."DUH" BECAUSE IT SEEMS THE POLICE DIDN'T CARE. BUT THIS IS GOING ON EVERY WHERE SO WHATS NEW THEY WILL PAY THE FAMILY AND THE SCUM BAGS WILL CONTINUE TO BE DIRT BAGS. WE SHOULD HAVE THEM WHERE GANG COLOR'S BECAUSE THATS WHO THEY REMIND ME OF.THEY DON'T SERVE AND PROTECT THEY JUST DO WHAT THEY WANT. "

beaten wrote on Feb 27, 2008 2:05 AM:

" Stalker! Yeah they do need money! Ask Candace when she plans on paying her 80 year old mother back for buying their house back out of foreclosure so they all had a roof over their heads. Then ask her why she won't let the children visit their grandmother or aunt. this is nothing you should learn the rest of the story. Right Candy??? single lives in Florida, Valpariso, no children, all the "degrees" big paying jobs...NOT!!! check the dating sites you've run across her somewhere...I'm sure "

You're kidding right? wrote on Feb 27, 2008 1:57 AM:

" Why are there so many comments about what the WOMAN may have said to the cop to PROVOKE him? 'Ya bunch of hillbillies!! Regardless, this is open assault!!! She is irate (why couldn't the cops calm the situation) and her sons are trying hard to push her away from the scene. But, she is nowhere near that cop (she was turned and walking away) when he pounced. And pounced is what he did. HE wasn't done FIGHTING with HER. And when does an officer (or any man) get to punch a woman in the face and pull a gun on her for words. WOW! THAT IS A BAD COP!!!!!!!!!!!!! "

hobart resident wrote on Feb 27, 2008 12:43 AM:

" the people have only heard and were able to view part of a surveillance video which was edited to show what looks appealing to an audience. We were not there and there are always two sides to every story and many of you have no clue what it is like to be a police officer and I if you were at that scene how would you have dealt with an unknown situation. Police officers have families to and they want to go home every night but obviously to many people that doesn't matter because you don't know if the people inside have a gun or were yelling grab a gun a knife or if the people in the yard are armed. Before you judge someone on how they do their job why don't you do it first because I am sure you are perfect in every way and you don't have to worry about getting killed everyday and not coming home to see your children. "

beaten wrote on Feb 27, 2008 12:31 AM:

" Did this video reveal any foul or abusive language used to provocate the actions of the police officers? Does this video reveal any disregard of any orders or instructions given by the police in this matter. Once the woman was guided away from the conflict why did she return...was it maybe to get the officers in front of the camera's field of view? I smell a set up...Also she wasn't shedding any tears when she beat her brother just a few months after he had undergone open heart surgery. "

Concerned Resident wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:49 PM:

" You people who are defending the police officers in this case are disgusting. What more do you need? It's in plain black and white. The cops are beating these people up for no reason! And even if the woman was hurling insults at them, that is still NO reason to start beating the hell out of these people. The reason they had the video camera out was because of previous vandalism in the area. I respect what police officers do in protecting the community. But it is far to often when these men and women who are suppose to enforce the law actually abuse and break the law... "

SAY WHAT? wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:27 PM:

" my gosh cant you people think logically?
seriously
these people were calling in about a crime that was basically being commited i know as a nearby resident there are teenagers that run around this part of the neighborhood and yes at 10 at night even on a school night
what if he wouldve overlooked one of these kids and hit them?

i think the police were in the wrong but dont be quickly to judge i was always taught never to hit a woman no matter what so were these officers never tauhgt this or what?
grow up hobart stop acting like children the truth will be told

god will make sure evil will parish in a time like this "

Schererville wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:27 PM:

" This woman looks like someone who would just be rude and bitchy with a person if she didn't get her way. And just what is the police supposed to do with someone speeding down the street? Chances are that person is already gone, by the time the police arrives, so what is the deal with these people. They truly arrested the right people, because in order for the police to react the way they did, the family must have done something serious. It's people like her that make the police hate the general public. "

Media Hounds wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:24 PM:

" Seems to me they like to be in the limelight alot. Turns out that in February of 2001, they were in the paper, because Candy and James's kid ended up in the ER after their 2 year old went to the table, grabbed some hear and diabetes medication and started eating like like candy. The kid is fine, she was lucky, but to me, it's not newsworthy. Aparently the parents, thought it was. I'm sorry, but she looks like she's got a mean mouth on her. For all we know, she could have provoked the officer..he's human too. He can get angry too. I'm siding with the police. She's probably a mean individual. "

appallled wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:46 PM:

" I'm sure the Olig family was just sitting around one night and someone said "hey, I've got a great idea. Why don't we stage an incident with the Hobart police and take the city for 5 mill! We might have to put up with some broken bones or jail time but it will be worth it! Honey, you set up the camera and I'll call the police. Places, everyone! Get a clue, people. "

Voice Of Reason wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:26 PM:

" Here is the problem, not just in Hobart, but everywhere. People think that the law should be an answer to their anger.

Law enforcement is not about emotion. Police should use violence to stop violence, or protect others; not because of insults.

Even if a drunk driver injures someone, a judge should not exact a punishment that goes outside of the exercise of judicial responsibility (like a wrecked car on the guilty party's lawn).

Your appointed, or elected, judiciary servents are not your parents, and should not punish with the emotion of an angry parent.

If you think the officers, in this case are being victimized, that is emotion. If you are insulting anyone standing up for the officers, you are reacting emotionally.

You will never get someone to do better, or grow up, by calling them names. It takes listening to them, and trying reasonable debate when you do not agree.

Remember that when you disagree with your spouse, child or neighbor. Perhaps, then you will avoid a punch to the face, or the loss of your job.
"

Laughing Out Loud wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:18 PM:

" I think this entire incident is absolutely STAGED!!! These people are out to ruin somebody else's life and career because they are too lazy to get one of their own!
I think they set themselves up. The video is more detrimental to their characters and action than the police officers. I can't wait to see the video from the police officers. I hope the Olig's get what is coming to them. "

To Serve and Protect wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:17 PM:

" I thought cops were suppose to serve and protect not beat and bludgeon. Even if this woman made slurs or any rude comments what right does the officer have to punch her and pull a gun on her. This is another example how cops think they are above the law. Even if provoked these officers could have handled this differently. This was like an imature school yard fight. I hope they are awarded millions and these idiots lose their jobs. Or better yet let the victims here beat and hancuff their sister, mother, or grandmother.... "

Smart wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:12 PM:

" Hopefully the police officers can get back to work soon. Maybe people will learn to respect authority. What an great example for your kids. Screaming obscenities and charging at police officers is probably not the smartest thing to do. These people obviously just want some free taxpayer money. Police have better things to do then stop at your house and listen to a middle age woman shout nasty things at them and charge after them. "

andy wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:05 PM:

" Did a search on the 'Olig' name, and it appears that in April 2003, their home burned in Hobart & the community rallied around them....it would then appear that this family is not 'disliked' or troublemakers in Hobart?? Altho I would ask why they have a security camera outside their home, not a cheap option.

The truth will come out either one way or another. However I think that regardless of what anyone did to provoke the officer, he had no right to attack...sticks & stones may break yr bones, but names will never hurt you...Lets start teaching that again in kindergarten. "

lisa wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:59 PM:

" after looking at the video for a 3rd time.... that may have been pepper spray NOT a gun!!!!! the officer was trying to protect himself from an irate female that was interfering in the arrest of her family member... i say kudos to the police officers for doing such a wonderful job, no body got seriously hurt during this altercation. "

former hobart resident wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:30 PM:

" Its absolutely ridiculous the whole police force is they will go out of there way if someone has done something wrong or been caught. But a cop family or cop can get away with anything in Hobart Im so happy this happen the Police in HOBART deserves this. "

schumacher wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:29 PM:

" with out audio this video has no value to add. The officer appears to be going for the guy behind the woman which then the woman pushed aside where she proceeded to fake for the camera that the family placed in the perfect spot. The cops acted justified and if I was a lake county tax payer I would be ticked if the county gives this lady money. I will be ticked if the state is involved with this family provoked non sense. "

lisa wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:26 PM:

" after looking at the tape yet again... i am confused... where did the officer pull his gun? how did he cuff her so fast without reholstering his gun? what did he do throw it on the ground? i still say the family is trying to get rich quick...
"

Gonzo wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:12 PM:

" People rely on the police too much, the police don't have all of the answers. The police are here for people that aren't evolved enough to handle situations on their own. Looks to me the oligs family love this type of behavior and all they respond to is physical confrontations. "

FIRE OLIVER wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:12 PM:

" That moron should be doing time, I hope he and the others are all fired and prosecuted. I also hope he loses everything he has as the result of a civil suit. Guys like this have no business carrying a gun or wearing a badge! "

Union Twp Resident wrote on Feb 26, 2008 8:50 PM:

" I don't know what happened to turn this in to the brawl it became BUT there seems to alot of " agressive " movement by this family . And with no audio it hard to tell exactly who provoked who .
To the police bashers on here , Let us remember there's good and bad in all professions , and most of our police officers are good . I would say the truth is somewhere in the middle on this case and will come out . "

Stalkers Victim wrote on Feb 26, 2008 8:33 PM:

" To all of you stupid people defending the Oligs can you not see from the body language and what is going on that she was provoking the officer?? and that it was her that started it all. she wanted the last word and instead got knocked out. You know what even if you are a woman if you're man enough to throw a punch you're man enough to take a punch. She deserved everything that her and her family has gotten. all these people are looking for is some money and some one to pitty them. Karma. What comes around. Goes around. People of that class will never learn. "

Set-Up wrote on Feb 26, 2008 7:51 PM:

" Why were there 3 officers responding to a traffic complaint? Why was there a video camera set up to record the complaint? There is way more to the story than the video shows. The Oligs provoked the cops and caught the whole thing on tape, w/o audio of course. "

outraged wrote on Feb 26, 2008 7:51 PM:

" There is no excuse possible for the actions of the police officers involved, whether they were "provoked" or not. This is just another example of a troubling nationwide trend of police violence and harrasement against the citizenry. Fortunately for the family they have proof of the abuse committed against them and I hope they take it as far as they need to to put these dangerous, irresponsible jerks away. We should remember this case the next time some junior G man blows away someone in their front yard because he "thought they had a gun."
"

wondering???? wrote on Feb 26, 2008 7:47 PM:

" don't the cop cars have cameras in their squad cars with AUDIO?? I think that will tell alot of the story. "

Dr. Who wrote on Feb 26, 2008 7:43 PM:

" Sherry,

Next time you pop off to someone I guess you feel it will be allright for them to beat you up!

The security camera was there because the Hobart police do not do their jobs! "

hobart201 wrote on Feb 26, 2008 7:29 PM:

" The officer should know better.Have some self control,if it were 2 citizens they,d both be in jail..Hobart police try leading by example.. "

logical thinker wrote on Feb 26, 2008 7:16 PM:

" Lets take a closer look and use some logic to disect this video. As the family tries to walk back into the house the mother is being aggressive towards the officers. At the time the officer approaches her, she under arrest for disorderly conduct. When the supposed strike takes place, the female aggressively motions towards the officer. He then PUSHES her back, NOT PUNCHES her, look closely. Then later while the officers are attempting to arrest the other family members agian the female attempts to attack the officers. She is the aggressor! I would dare anyone to walk into a 4+ person confrontation, not use any force and take all of them into custody. GREAT JOB HPD, dont worry there actually are some good citizens out there. "

Cookie wrote on Feb 26, 2008 6:57 PM:

" Looks to me the mother couldn't control herself. It also looks like she attacked the officer first. The rest of the family seems to want to go into the house but she is more interested in fighting with the cops. "

Andy Taylor wrote on Feb 26, 2008 6:56 PM:

" Para-military police training is a wonderful thing, don't cha think?

This family needs to think twice about requesting public servants do their job. "

Look Deeper wrote on Feb 26, 2008 6:48 PM:

" I agree with the 1:59 poster. I too was outraged after first viewing this. However, I viewed it several more times and it does appear that the family showed aggression first. It appears that the a small altercation takes place outside of the fence and that the officers followed the family into the yard to presumably arrest one of the family members. Once in the yard it appears things got more heated and an extreme stance of resistance was taken by the family. It even appears that just before the punch, a juvenile runs and grabs the office's gun belt. The punch may have been going too far, but I for one have never been confronted with four adults and a child who appear to be ready to attack me. Just be careful to judge before all the facts are in. The camera may not show everything. "

cittycat wrote on Feb 26, 2008 6:45 PM:

" After reading the former comments, it amazes me that people are still so quick to judge these officers. The body language of the Olig's suggests that they are provoking these police officers. However, without sound and all of the facts I don't know how anyone can condemn anyone. I've known officer Mokris my entire life. He is absolutely there to make sure justice is done, and always, always follows the law to the letter. It's who he is and what he does. So, before judging anyone
wait for all of the facts and let the jury decide. "

Debbie wrote on Feb 26, 2008 6:37 PM:

" There are way to many strange aspects to this video. You can see that the police remain outside of the yard and do not enter until something else occurs. I find it hard to believe that the family just walked calmly away, cameras filming, saying they would contact an official. This would not prompt an officer to run up in the yard. But some foul language and insults would. There is a lot more to this situation than we no. Plus there is no audio. How convienient. I am with the theory that this family set it up for the money. An entire family in the front yard to report a speeding car? I support the officers until we find out more information. They live in danger every day. Like the citizens, they deserve basic respect. I don't think that they got it. And the second two officers seemed to be properly handling what turned into a family fight. Why attack them? "

ANONUSER wrote on Feb 26, 2008 6:32 PM:

" I think the first punch could have been avoided. but the Oligs were out of hand, you can tell that without the audio..it kind of looks like a set up, how ironic, this incident occured right in front of the camera that they had. Yes I think the officer should be punished but I don't think they should get paid for this incident. BELIEVE me they're looking foward to this lawsuit!! they provoked this in some way. WHERE ARE THEY WITNESSES?? somebody had to see it. but The paper does tell a one sided story, which is no suprise with NWI Times. "

New Vision wrote on Feb 26, 2008 6:16 PM:

" This will be the first real test for Mayor Snedecor. The level of integrity, transparency and accountability he demonstrates regarding this incident will define just what we can expect over the next four years. Mayor Snedecor, we are watching closely. "

Common Problem wrote on Feb 26, 2008 6:11 PM:

" Unfortunately this is a common problem with the folks that hang the badge on their shirt. It is not all inclusive but it is real, and it is there. When they put the badge on many feel they are above the law. I have seen it from numerous police friends and police relatives, and they think its funny. The fact is that so little of it is actually ever captured on tape.

These people should be fired immediately. They should be arrested and incarcerated. Lord knows if this was a common man against a cop there would be no alibi or empathy.

Putting on the badge is like climbing behind the wheel of a car. The psyche changes and the belief of being untouchable arise. The must be held accountable for their actions! There is NO EXCUSE!

And yes. There is a code amongst officers so all four fall with their brother. "

Glenn wrote on Feb 26, 2008 6:08 PM:

" A cop punched a civilian Woman in the face........ Enough said. That family couldn't have said anything to provoke that. "

Life long Hobart Resident wrote on Feb 26, 2008 5:39 PM:

" I am not surprised to see this abuse of power by HPD. This department is not, and has not been "community friendly" for a very long time. I'm glad someone finally has proof on video. I agree with the previous comment, time for a Clean Sweep of this department. "

Life long Hobart Resident wrote on Feb 26, 2008 5:34 PM:

" I am not surprised to see this video displaying abuse of power by HPD, I'm just happy someone finally caught it on tape. This department is not, and has not been "community friendly" for a very long time.
I agree with the previous comment, time for a clean sweep. "

anarchy wrote on Feb 26, 2008 5:20 PM:

" Police in hobart get stupider everyday. This is BULL. "

Chris wrote on Feb 26, 2008 5:16 PM:

" Having lived in Hobart my whole life, this is no surprise to me.I have seen and heard about things like this my whole life. If a Hobart cop comes around you better be ready to stand down or take your punishment along with trumped up charges. The people in charge now have been part of the problem. Lake County or The State Police should be investigating this issue. "

Lisa wrote on Feb 26, 2008 5:03 PM:

" I think the fault lies on both sides of the fence. Police officers should be above being taunted & provoked into physically hitting an unarmed individual. I saw no provocation from the family that was life threatening to the police. No matter what the Olig's said, the cops should have used a little restraint instead of turning the situation into a street fight. This is a sad situation if a police officer is provoked into violence from what... a slanderous remark. Shame on you! I too am curious as to how the new mayor/former chief plans to handle this situation. And to the Olig's, although you did not deserve what happened on the night in question, one would have to say after viewing the video, why would you stand there and argue with them. I can understand your anger with the situation of them not doing their job, but honestly how much of a hillbilly do you have to be. You could have just said thanks for nothing, I will take this up with your boss, said nothing else & turned around to walk in your house. Instead, everyone acted like teenage punks (on both sides). What a sad situation! "

ACTIONS SPEAK LOUDER THAN WORDS wrote on Feb 26, 2008 5:02 PM:

" The police officers should have walked away while the entire family was walking in the opposite direction! SIMPLE LOGICAL CONCLUSION. END OF INCIDENT!! Who cares what Mrs. "O" was saying. Learn SOME PEOPLE SKILLS boys!

What transpired here is TERRIFYING TO SAY THE LEAST!! Especially BRANDISHING A FIREARM.

The camera WORKS both WAYS - don't forget it.

I've seen worse: See Cleveland Strip Search (Two male officers and three female officers STRIP SEARCHING A WOMAN, who, in fact, was the VICTIM) Big Lawsuit on this one. "

Kelley wrote on Feb 26, 2008 5:00 PM:

" Funny that the incident was caught on tape. Sounds like a staging to me! I would hope that if provoked that an officer of the law would take matters in a professional manner, I didn't see anything but the police handling an unruly situation.. Looks to me like that family is out to make somebody look bad. "

homeslice wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:55 PM:

" That might the funniest video I have ever seen, Dont ya know you dont mess with po lice!!!!
Those people should have left it alone, I would have tasered the big girl though. "

Hobart Gal wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:55 PM:

" I don't care who is at fault, but why sue for money? Why not sue for the officers to be removed from the force? Everyone wants to get rich the easy way. "

jean wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:54 PM:

" a taser or pepper spray would have been just as effective. what was the speeding incident anyway? the oligs looked a little sheepish in the paper today. where's all that outrage now? "

rich wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:48 PM:

" I have a security system with cameras,but they face my entrances. Why would someone have one facing the street unless they had a motive? "

hobart citizen wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:43 PM:

" these officers need to be reminded that they are public sevants not public assaultants , what happened to serve and protect , this family was clearly assaulted , and with a deadly weapon involved they need to file criminal charges with the county or the state police , this isint the first time the hobart police have acted in a irresponsible fashion , it seems like you can read something derogitve about them weekly , the community must perge itself of these self serving bullies and hire more responsible public servants "

Patrick wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:39 PM:

" Wow!! My wife and I just watched this video. What could that woman have said that would have provoked this officer to use force and than point at gun at her. Maybe they provoked the cops, but what happened to this woman was excessive. Shame on these police officers!! Get a grip man!!! "

BlueMan wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:35 PM:

" This is just another case of people blaming the Police. You cannot even hear what was said in the video, so how do you know the Olig's didn't say anything to provoke an altercation? And who the heck cares about a speeding car on your street at 1000PM? Get over it and go to bed. You wonder why Police aren't more productive, it's because they have to keep the public happy and respond to calls like that. Hey Olig's, if you would have just went to bed none of this would have happened in the first place..... Like you've never sped down a street before. DONT CALL THE POLICE FOR STUPID THINGS ANYMORE!!!!! "

Ruben wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:34 PM:

" Are you guys kidding me?? Who threw the first punch???? These officer should be locked up! This kind of stuff is going on all the time in Chicago and nobody is reporting this stuff. Thank God that they have film this! I bet the cops would have said that they have never hit the person at all. They threw the first punch!! Can't these Officers handle any type of words to them?? IF not why are they in the Police force?? "

picture clear wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:27 PM:

" It is clear to me that the family did not listen to the orders of the police and were very upset and were agressive to the cops. The cops are not there to come in second place in a disturbance. They should have listened, then went inside and there would have been no problem they were pressing the police and refused their order. I bet if there was audio this family would have been heard starting all this mess. After everyone was cuffed the police stopped. No further "beating" they got the situation under control and left with there prisoners case closed!!! "

brett wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:25 PM:

" Thank god for the video they had, this would have never been an issue had the Oligs not had surveillance. Dont think for one minute that the cops would have acted this way knowing there was video. Typical of not just Hobart but the state of the police state that is now the United States. Just look at the abuse of power. Throw them in jail and prosecute them to the fullest degree.In addition to civil charges Hobart damn well better pay. Oligs were just reporting a crime and have become victims of a vicious abuse of power. "

Hobart resident wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:25 PM:

" The Olig's are known for trying to sue various people/organizations. "

mm wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:20 PM:

" I was also harrassed by an officer in my town. It started as a "prank" my child was involved in and ended up turning into court and probation for my child due to the officer stating that I was uncooperative when all that happened was I had asked questions regarding the situation. Hmmm it seems like alot of people have had problems with the police (bullies). "

The Irish Hot Rod wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:13 PM:

" Do we know the truth about what provoked the attack. I can't judge the cop to be wrong or right just by watching this tape. Growing up in Hobart and going to school with then two future cops, I've known a lot of Hobart Police and Fire Fighters and those that I know have been brought up with the knowledge and the practice of what is right and what is wrong. Hobart as well as any other city or town has bad apples over time, it's a shame that one bad apple spoils the basket. The same holds true to any group of people. I just hope that the public and others don't pre-judge the rest of the police force because of the actions of a couple of, not proven guilty just yet, officers that may or may not have abused their authority. All I ask of the public is to not pre-judge these officers until all of the evidence is in, and once it is in I'm sure the police force will do what is necessary but most important, what is right.
"The irish Hot Rod" "

jd wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:13 PM:

" I really believe this family provoked this, but at the same time the cops shouldnt have gotten physical. Even if these people were out of line. It is odd that this all happened to be filmed, but again the cop should know better. So why dont we know the police's side of the story? "

TO SHERRY wrote on Feb 26, 2008 4:02 PM:

" If you would have read the article you would have read that they have a home surveillance system. Also just because you know the family of officer Oliver and say that they are good people doesn't mean anything. Alot of good people turn out to be not so good. "

Intellegence wrote on Feb 26, 2008 3:57 PM:

" Thanks SHERRY, for showing some intellegence on the situation as I said earlier. This looks like it was staged by the Olig family. "

Hey Sherry wrote on Feb 26, 2008 3:57 PM:

" Maybe the video is set up all the time to watch over the property, mine is. It is relatively cheap to install and keep it running. Somebody breaks into my house, I'll have them in all their glory for the police to beat up or arrest, I suppose. I think the cops were surprised to learn they are now TV stars! Good job, Oligs! "

Nearby Resident wrote on Feb 26, 2008 3:55 PM:

" I could not care less how long you have known these policemen. They did wrong PLAIN AND SIMPLE!!!! Watching that video made me sick! These are the people we want to protect and serve us??? "

Intellegence wrote on Feb 26, 2008 3:44 PM:

" As I said Before, This family really needs to be investigated more than the officers involved in the incident!!! When I mean investigated, I mean that it should be looked into if the family was on the verge of bankruptcy or something similar and not just trying to pull a quick "GET RICH SCAM".(for example) "

Sandy wrote on Feb 26, 2008 3:41 PM:

" These officers and I say this loosely were not aware they were being watched by a video camera. Thank God for modern tech. Hey Mr. Oliver are you proud of yourself!!! I hope you dont treat your wife like that. God help her if you do. I watched the video and it looks like police brutality to me. "

Sherry wrote on Feb 26, 2008 3:37 PM:

" Officer Paul Oliver grew up in my neighborhood and I have known him since he was a young boy. He comes from a good family and has never been in trouble. I watched the video and it is unclear what provoked the incident since there is no sound to determine who is saying what. I question why a video camera would be set up to tape a traffic complaint unless there was an ulterior motive? It is almost like it was a staged situation? I have witnessed Officer Oliver while on duty and he was professional and kind.
"

AND wrote on Feb 26, 2008 3:35 PM:

" If doesn't matter what this family said to the police. They have NO right hitting a women and for that matter pulling a gun on her. "

Dennis wrote on Feb 26, 2008 3:15 PM:

" To: Family shows aggression

How did the family show aggression, they were going back into their house when the cops, who were on the other side of the fence, followed them. Newsflash: Words alone cannot provoke a physical altercation under Indiana law. It is not a legal defense. Words are not an excuse to hit someone and these policemen know or should have known that. The cops were WRONG!!!! I hope they personally have to pay for an attorney to defend themselves. This will cost Hobart some money as it should and I would sue each officer involved also. "

Agression First??? wrote on Feb 26, 2008 3:10 PM:

" The family was smart enough to walk away when the conversion got out of hand. It was that Paul Oliver who escalated the situation to the point of violence. Those of you who are condoning this behavior have warped minds. I'm sure if Paul Oliver knew that the cameras were rolling, he would have handled this situation differently. This video should serve as a message to all of the cops nationwide that some of us aren't taking this anymore. As a matter of fact, I am installing a camera system in my car. I pray for the day that some cop, like Paul Oliver, to do something like this to me, my wife or teenage sons who fit your profile of a gangbanger until you see their report cards. We need the money. "

Porter Co Res wrote on Feb 26, 2008 3:05 PM:

" I know the Oligs and there is no doubt in my mind that they were saying things that shouldn't be said. However, where is the professionalism these police officers are supposed to have? If they didn't want to take the report all they had to do was walk away! They didn't have to go into the yard and start physically abusing an unarmed woman and then point a loaded weapon at her.

Maybe when the police officers have lost their jobs and their homes they will understand that they didn't have those rights! Don't abuse your power. Your job is to serve and protect! "

my 2 cents wrote on Feb 26, 2008 2:59 PM:

" It looks staged to me as if someone was trying to set the stage if you will, and catch something on video. If I was the atty for the P.D. I would want to know how long the family had this security system in place. The police also seem over aggressive. What a sad mess for everone envolved. Police need to remain above and in control of any situation.Police should never let words provoke them into the behavior that they are swore to protect the public from...No matter what.It would have been interesting if there was also audio. "

what??? wrote on Feb 26, 2008 2:48 PM:

" You can tell by body language that the olig provoked the attack. SOunds to me like they are just looking for money. yes, its rough to watch. but who started it "

Mike D wrote on Feb 26, 2008 2:33 PM:

" It is unfortunate when ever an incident like this happens. Policeman have a very difficult thankless job. If the Oligs had been beating the police it wouldn't have made the papers or nobody would care. It is no wonder that police try to cover for other policemen. The public certainly will give them the benefit of the doubt. Next time you need help call an Olig. "

watched the video wrote on Feb 26, 2008 2:27 PM:

" well, i watched it, and even tho mom and dad taught us never to hit a woman.....
honestly i tried to sort out who was who. it wasnt easy because of the distance. but if you watch very closely, it looks like even tho dad and the boys were walking away, mom was still in the cops face. and i really think i saw her hit the cop first.
yes, i could be wrong, but id like the cops story before i declare her a victim. if she did what i think she did, he was completely justified in taking her down, and all her protectors too. "

All the Same wrote on Feb 26, 2008 2:27 PM:

" What happened on this video is exactly why people have no respect for the police anymore. What could this women have said that it caused a grown man to punch her in the face? Even if she somehow insulted him, he should have simply arrested her. Its not just Hobart policemen, its all policemen. They are all the same. They all wear black clothing, with black boots, and black leather gloves and maintain shaved heads like a gestapo troop. Children in my day would walk up to a cop and grab their hand for comfort and security, now they are too intimidating
to even approach. In their mind every one is a crook and only the ones that belong in their special brotherhood should be given any special considerations. "

AbbieJoe wrote on Feb 26, 2008 2:23 PM:

" These cops are a TOTAL disgrace to not only the police force, but to the human race as well! Anyone seeing this report would avoid moving to Hobart, and be afraid to stop if puled over by a police car - hard to tell what these bullies would do to anyone. Shame on you Hobart police and leaders. Get rid of these cops before they end up killing someone they don't like. "

Doesn't add up wrote on Feb 26, 2008 2:03 PM:

" If the camera was used for security then why was it pointed at the road instead of the house? Something is wrong here, it just doesn't add up. "

BETTER OFF? wrote on Feb 26, 2008 2:00 PM:

" Man, I moved out of LaPorte County because of the serious corruption over there, but I am starting to see that this type of behavior has infected the system in the entire state of Indiana. Do you think that it could be a nationwide problem? Now, what would make a person think that? The system is out of control! People need to wake up and make these people follow rank and file, as it was intended to be followed. They keep changing the laws to suit themselves, and the average person can't prove it. I am proud of these people for getting it on tape, and I pray that their case is one that will help wake up the Federal government that there are some serious issues with these so-called pros at the local levels. The abuse is becoming almost communist. "

Family shows aggression first wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:59 PM:

" The more I watch the video the more I wonder what is wrong with this picture. First, why is the entire family in the yard? The parents couldn't talk to the police without them? Second, you can tell the police are being provoked by the body language of the family, the "mother" shows aggression before the cops do. Even at one point it appears one of the kids tries to restrain the "mother" without much good. Just because you have freedom of speech doesn’t mean you should run your mouth to provoke an incident. The "mother" just showed her kids that running your mouth and showing disrespect to the wrong person will get your behind kicked. She looks like trouble, and is trouble from what I see here. "

joe public wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:45 PM:

" Interested in what the neighbor had to say, they were probably using bad language but the fact that the officer came accross the fence line onto private property to futher ingage in this incident is the first step to a bad situation. It should have never come to that. I hope all parties can come to a agreement and nobody should get rich but only fairly compensated. The officers in question should be investigated for past complaints (if any)to paint the whole picture. "

Hobart resident wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:44 PM:

" I have lived in Hobart nearly 30 years. I have neighbors across the street who have police at their house almost on a weekly basis. I have seen the neighbor get very vocal, using words no one has the right to say. I have even seen this neighbor get right up in the officers faces and continue spouting vulgar words. The officers usually just left them with a warning. I have never seen an attack like the one I saw on this video. I was appalled at how these people were treated. These officers should at least have had some disciplinary actions taken against them. I can't blame the Oligs for suing. No matter what was said there was no physical threat against the officers and no reason for them to strike her and pull a gun. "

Their Neighbor wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:41 PM:

" Having lived next to this family for many years, I am not surprised. They have harassed the HPD endlessly! Let's see if the Olig family will hand over tapes from any of their other thousand calls. I doubt it. The whole family is whacked! The Prosecution needs to interview the neighbors if they want witnesses. "

Outraged wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:40 PM:

" After viewing the aforementioned/seen video, I am truly sickened and outraged at the behavior of the Hobart police. I am however, not surprised. The Hobart police dress in a "swat" like manner and as my elders always told me, you act like you look and dress. That comment dates me, however, I think that it {the comment} is as true today as when I grew up in the "60's. I am not shocked or surprised, however. Through my own and my families personal experiences with some of the officers on the Hobart force, I have come to the conclusion as well as observation that all police officers should obtain, at least, a Bachelors degree in Criminology and/or related subjects. If nothing else, in order for the officer to deduce incidents or problems in an intelligent manner. Like the old adage goes, "You get what you pay for."!!!!!!! "

pablo wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:34 PM:

" After viewing the film, why should you call the police for assistance? You may be the one locked up! Will the new mayor deal with this or sweep it under the rug? Fire those 3 (not cops) bullies! "

Famile Friend wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:26 PM:

" The Hobart area is so bad now because you call the cops and they show up and do nothing or they dont show up at all that you have to have a camara on your house. Well the Olig family did and now you have people saying it was a setup, that is totally not true.People can think what they want but the Olig's are a good family and never did anything to deserve what happened to them. That day they just didnt want to do their job. Well guess what now the real truth comes out and now people can see how the hobart cops really are, I hope they all end up in jail and being terminated from being an officer in any state again. My heart goes out to the family and I hope that they get the justice and money they deserve. I also think that the children who where standing outside should get some money for being tramitized for having to see there family getting beat up for no reason by cops, Tell me who are they supposed to call if they need help now. To the cops you should be ashamed of yourselves "

Brian wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:22 PM:

" This is apalling! Police officers are there to protect and serve. Maybe the Oligs made a remark, but that give the officers no right to treat citizens and taxpayers that way. If they were in thier front yard, they have no right to act like this. They should have written a report and drove away. And above all, a male police officer should never hit a female, unless in a dangerous struggle, when imediate danger is imminent. These officers should be suspended, charged and jailed for thier unjust actions. I respect police officers with the the highest regard, but this is unnecesary. I hope the Oligs receive a settlement for this, and the police department needs to control thier officers in a more professional manner. "

Thin Blue Line wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:21 PM:

" Did it ever occure to you that when the male subject was standing between Mrs. Olig and the Officer, that Mrs. Olig may have placed her hands on the Officer? "

Thank God for the Hobart Police wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:13 PM:

" Wow, it is great listening to everyone's comments that have personal bias against the police. Once again it is the minority of these idiotic comments posted by people that have had bad experiences with the police, and the sad thing is the politicians looking to make a name for themselves will push for some radical uneeded changes that will only make things worse off for honest hard working people that need the police. There is two sides to every story and thank god for the witness against the olig family. everyone is critic, they couldn't walk one minute in a police officers shoes. Hey Chris, mall security doesn't count as being a policeman. And if there were security cameras in every house in Gary, you would really see how people are prisoners in their own homes because of crime and the police not being able to do their jobs. "

what wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:12 PM:

" I don't know what you people are looking at. First of all the picture is not that clear and there're bodies blocking the complete view. We don't have audio either. I didn't see anyone being beaten up. In fact, I saw the police trying to keep control, to get the family members down and contained on the ground. I saw plain as day Mrs. Olgis charge the officer(s) even after being knocked down. She never even sat down, though you can see they are trying to get her to. We don't know the whole story, we don't see the whole story, everyone's perception is different, we hear nothing...how can you just make a judgement? And I too question the motive. What would possibley go so sour if the Olgis family was simply calling about a speeding car? It doesn't make sense...and funny how it all just happens to be on tape. I don't trust anyone anymore, there needs to be a thorough investigation and people should refrain from quick judgement till all the facts are in. "

Not taking sides wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:06 PM:

" If you watch the video, the woman was lunging at the officer several times before he hit her. I think the officers could have handled the situation differently, but I don't think the Oligs are completely innocent either. "

Judi wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:04 PM:

" I viewed the video and that police officer was totally out of hand and should be suspended off the force without pay and also the other police officers. There is no need for physical violence from anyone espically a police officer, they are officers of the law and they might want to rethink their position and what they have choosed in life, to uphold the law not beat and arrest innocent people for reporting a crime!!! "

Camera doesn't lie! wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:02 PM:

" Throw those clowns off the force and into prison. "

Only One Side Being Told wrote on Feb 26, 2008 1:01 PM:

" Here we go again, the police have been convicted by all of the mindless cop bashers. I love how some of these "experts" can determine that the officers are automatically wrong from a poor grainy clip without any audio that was released by a newspaper. I'm sure there is more to the story than what is in the paper. Then again the media is the supreme force in cop bashing. Wait for some facts before you go spouting out your anti police hatred. "

concerned wrote on Feb 26, 2008 12:51 PM:

" TO SERVE AND PROTECT!!! Not to beat up and abuse! I hope they sue the pants off them and those officers get their just penance. How disgusting! TOTAL ABUSE OF THEIR AUTHORITY! "

Hobart tax payer wrote on Feb 26, 2008 12:42 PM:

" As a Hobart resident I am appalled! I lived down the street from the Olig's and I can say nobody is perfect but they are law-abiding, taxpaying citizens, trying to raise their family in a proposed safe community! What were the police thinking pulling a gun with children around especially when they were not being threatened by a gun.They need to be placed on leave without pay as of this morning!
I am MAD as a tax paying Hobart resident my taxes are paying for their the unrationalization of not walking away from verbal slander, I think it is still a constitutional right to voice opinion's. And that is all the Olig's look guilty of. The department should use the taxpayer money to teach police officers to walk away from freedom of speech situations instead of using their power to abuse the tax money to settle their lawsuits.
I believe we all want answers,especially the taxpayers in Hobart,(we try to teach our children to walk away from verbal abuse instead of fighting).
Please Olig's seek medical advice for your children also,this incedent will haunt them for the rest of their lives. They will probably never trust another police officer. "

nieghbor wrote on Feb 26, 2008 12:35 PM:

" The Olig's are always calling the police on stupid things.These officers are tired of their time being wasted because the Olig's like drama.
I watched the video and I do not think the police were in the wrong.
She charged the officer.
"

lisa wrote on Feb 26, 2008 12:34 PM:

" If you look closely she lunged at the police officer first. Where'e the audio when you need it. "

SOMETHING ELSE wrote on Feb 26, 2008 12:34 PM:

" I THINK BOTH PARTIES ARE AT FAULT!!!TWO WRONGS DO NOT MAKE IT WRIGHT!!!!! "

Munster wrote on Feb 26, 2008 12:28 PM:

" Where was the brutality? I agree, I saw the family continually going at the officers and obviously not listening. Since there is no sound (how convenient) we have no clue as to what was said on either side. But I saw mom constantly going back to the cop, when he most likely was saying go in the house. I saw no problem here. "

Anonymous wrote on Feb 26, 2008 12:27 PM:

" Police prove again and again that they think they are above the law. How long before the people who pay them demand that these insulting, degrading officers are discharged and face maximum criminal assault charges. What makes them above the law? Why did these cops feel they could come onto private property in order to punch out a woman. They had no right without a warrant. Bad words are breaking their bones? It doesn't seem to matter what town or city in the U.S. because it happens over and over again. What happened to out civil liberties? The police are a joke and I have absolutely no respect for the VAST majority of them. "

Could Be Scam wrote on Feb 26, 2008 12:20 PM:

" First, I don't know what the conversation was. It is interesting that this family has a monitor and positioned perfectly to catch this skit. I would check if the family has been involved in insurance fraud also. Get a video monitor, call the police or any agency for that matter, and then file a claim. "

C.L.E. wrote on Feb 26, 2008 12:17 PM:

" It looks like Mrs. Olig was pushing the officer before he punched her. I do not think punching her was right, but it looks like she pushed the officer a few times before he did something about it. "

Hobart Police wrote on Feb 26, 2008 12:11 PM:

" I hope those idiots wearing the badges have retained some good attorneys, the video shows they will need them. GUILTY! "

wow wrote on Feb 26, 2008 12:10 PM:

" Police officers should be trained for all situations even with people yelling, screaming, etc. That is their job, that is what they signed up for. So, regardless of the fact that if she was in his face or not, yelling or not, he should be trained for that type of behavior and in no means do I believe the training involves punching someone in the face and pulling your gun out on them. If this was okay, do you realize how many officers would be punching people in the face on a daily basis - 80% of the people who got arrested would then walk in their jail cells with black eyes. It would be part of the arresting protocol. So for those of you saying that she was out of control - and he did the right thing. Think of what your really saying here, and what rights your really giving to an officer to conduct himself on every arrest situation. "

Former Cop wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:53 AM:

" If the Olig family was trying to set up those Hobart officers then they did a good job of it. I've been called every name in the book by citizens so I understand the urge to smack someone for mouthing off. But, there is this little oath that officers take when hired that superseded my human impulses. Either these idiots didn't take that oath or they forgot about it on that night. Either way, they are going to pay dearly. I'm just glad I never had an incident like that with those types because my report would have been the opposite of the lie they concocted to establish pc for criminal charges. "

To the neighbor!! wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:51 AM:

" So the Olig's were yelling at the police and saying threats? Did they threaten the police with physical harm? As a citizen, we are allowed free speach! Did they threaten physical harm to the police or did they threaten to go over their heads to the chief or to the Mayor? What was the threat? I don't care what was said, did she deserve a punch in the face or to have a gun pulled on her even though she was unarmed? Think about this, because it has to do with our civil rights! I have the right to question the authorities if I feel I'm being violated as a citizen. I have the right to question the politicians too! I have a right to yell on my property! I hope you answer this question!! "

2 Sides to Every Story wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:49 AM:

" I know there are always 2 sides to every story but in this case, the camera tells the truth. all 3 of the cops in the video should be fired, prosecuted, and sued in civil court! "

R U BLIND wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:42 AM:

" From what I see, the "lady" went at the police first. It appears the whole family were going after the police and they police were protecting themselves. Should the cop of decked her? Probably not, but in this day and age, shes LUCKY she didnt get shot for going after him.. Money money money..THEY WANT MONEY! Get a job like the rest of the world and quit looking for an easy way out! "

More from Nikki wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:40 AM:

" Then to pull a gun on her! What if he would have killed her, in front of her children. This is absolutely rediculous! Was she armed? NO! Was she bigger than the police? NO! She felt threatened on her own property by police who are suppose to care about the community. Hey! I am the first to thank our law enforcement for their duty and service! But one's who believe they are above the law, should be removed. They are a threat, not a protector. A male policeman PUNCHED an unarmed woman in the face! Tell me, what is OK with that? If her husband punched her in the face in front of police, the police would have arrested the husband. Why didn't the police arrest him for assault and battery? "

No control wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:34 AM:

" This is totally uncalled for! Even if the Olig's did say something to the police that was not called for! That doesn't give the right for the cop to hit her! Its called FREEDOM OF SPEECH! Thats what America's all about remember! They are suppost to protect us not harm us and as we all seen in the video they did just the opposite of that! Leave it to some Hobart cops to make our town look bad. I really think that Hobart needs to evaluate all of Hobart "FINEST" and clean house! I am so glad for security camaras they work wonders! I have a few of them on my house for people who would break into my house or steal one of my cars but now I also have it for the case one of your other cops decide to abuse another citizen. It is sad that it has to come do to that! To much power is somepeople's hands I guess! "

My Opinion wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:23 AM:

" This is why we have a Criminal Justice System, to find out who is at fault and who isn’t... It will give us all something to gossip about during the trial process. "

lisa wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:20 AM:

" the officers did nothing wrong in my eyes...just looks like the family is looking for a get rich quick.. looked to me like the family got out of control and then cried abuse when the police did their jobs.... "

Katie wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:18 AM:

" I am a professional in a business where I deal with the public everyday. It does not matter what the family "said" to provoke the police. It is the job of the police not to be provoked. There were several of thema and they should have handled the situation in a professional manner and never under any circumstances is it alright for a policeman to pull a gun on an unarmed woman. These police should be removed from their jobs and have to attend anger management classes. "

Puhleeze! wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:11 AM:

" I've watched this over and over trying to make sense of it. Seems the woman was the one to make the first physical move after one of the male family members is seen wildly throwing his arms. The cops have every right to defend themselves. And once a woman hits a man she deserves to be knoked out like a man. I'm so sick of comments that a man can't hit a woman even in defense. She wants to act like a man, take her down like one. And yes, I am a 30 year old woman. "

JERKS! wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:10 AM:

" Storm troopers like these make life more difficult for good policemen and women! There is no place for cops like this. "

Rico wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:08 AM:

" Thank GOD for video tapes. Even if the Oligs said something, is it right for an officer to to punch someone in the face. A women at that. What a fat loser. Hobart, shame on you. I hope the Olids take hobart to the cleaners. Noone deserves this kind of treatment in front of there children. I'm glad I don't live there. Hobart get rid of them fat losers. "

opinion wrote on Feb 26, 2008 11:00 AM:

" From what I can see no matter if the Olig's were saying anything or not. No one did anything to deserve that that kind of treatment. Think if that was you or your family. What would you what done about it? "

Charlie wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:59 AM:

" How can we have respect for the law when those that represent the law constantly abuse it. There is probably more to this than what we see and there does seem to be the neighbor with something to add. But this does appear to be abuse of authority and they must be accountable by law the same as the public would be. "

x-hobart res wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:58 AM:

" The police were obviously in the wrong no matter what. But seriously, millions??? If that is the case, I will install some good security equipment at my house and spend weeks calling and trying to provoke officers to hit me. I would let all 4 take their best shot for millions. "

protect and serve??? wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:52 AM:

" Anyone who watched the video that thinks the cop was justified for punching that lady is as crazy as those guys with the badges. Any "good" law enforcement officer will tell you that they're trained that even when a criminal tries to fight them the officers job is to subdue, handcuff, and arrest them. Not go UFC and start throwing punches till the last man (or woman) is standing. All three of these cops, especially "Mr. big man I can beat up a woman" should not only be stripped of thier badges forever, but also be arrested themselves. "

Beth wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:51 AM:

" Whatever, the family was obviously causing the problem. The lady was restrained and went back for more. The family is totally at wrong. The wife was definately going after the cops. People just looking for money. "

Ron? wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:49 AM:

" No excuse for hitting a woman like that? Maybe in your mind, but when it comes to law enforcement there is no difference between a confrontation with a man or a woman. If she is perceived as a threat, which if she most certainly can, then there is not "courtesy". Why should he take any chances just because she is a woman? Many, many women have hurt and killed law enforcement officers over the years. "

Tim wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:43 AM:

" C'mon people. The Olig's obviously provoked it and are looking to make some money on a frivlous law suit, and unfortuantely will. The police have a tough job and need to protect themselves. The Olig's were getting hostile towards them and the police had to protect themselves. It keeps on getting harder and harder to be a cop, when someone starting getting hostile with a cop, how is the cop supposed to know if thise person is going to do something stupid. And even worse, what if the person has a gun or knife. This is a sham and the people are hiljacks. My biggest question, why exactly did they have video surveillance on their house, how many people have video surveillance on their house. "

Lake County Five-0 wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:41 AM:

" "Innocent Taxpayer" has a good point. As a law enforcement officer myself let me say that most of the younger officers today have lost the "bedside manner". Instead of "How can I help you?" it's "How can I arrest you?"

A lot of it is because we have administrators now who push writing tickets and making arrests. The days of the old officers who took a drunk driver home instead of taking him to jail, and who gave warnings instead of tickets are long gone.

Now we have this new breed of cop like the ones who are on the tape. Young,cocky, and non-sympathetic. "

We need a change... wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:39 AM:

" In our society we are raised to fear the police for exactly these types of situations. I do not mean to say that there are not great policemen out there who put their lives on the line every day for the good of the public... but all too often the power of their authority corrupts their judgment and leads to abuses of people's constitutional rights. What we need is a real change in the hiring process and the training of police officers. That is the only way to protect society from these types of wayward cops. "

Portage resident wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:34 AM:

" What do you do when you're a victim of police abuse such as in this video and have no money to hire a lawyer to file your complaint? Can you do it yourself? There has to be something that can be done. This video was horrible! "

Video worth 1,000 Words wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:26 AM:

" The cops were wrong! They should lose their jobs and face criminal charges. There is no place for this kind of thing in law enforcement. Those of you that saw something other than what the video reflects are most likely police officers or family of the thugs in uniform that star in this video. Shame on You! "

Proud of Hobart PD wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:23 AM:

" What I see on that video is 3 police officer's safety in jeopardy. This woman had to be held back by family members as she tried to fight with the officers. They did what they are trained to do. If she wanted to be treated like a lady she should have acted like one. As for the other family members, what did you think was going to happen once you interfered and began fighting? Ms. Olig you should be embarrassed by your bar room behavior. "

jim morrison wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:21 AM:

" Looks like the Hobart police better take some pointers from the EC police I saw in the EC high school riot pictures.
Break out your masks "

FIRE THEM ALL! wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:19 AM:

" All the jerks with badges on this video tape should be doing time! I would love to be on the criminal jury! I hope the family gets millions for this!!!!! "

ashley and wendy wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:17 AM:

" no wonder this counrty is the way it is with all the crooked cops there are out there. this is a prime example. if these cops did this to this family, what else more severe have they done. question that... "

Just not sure wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:15 AM:

" To those who think this is a scam for money...if this was your family and they were having a verbal exchange with the police, would you find it ok for your family to be attacked, threatened with a gun and arrested? Think before you write your comments. I highly doubt you would be defending the police in that scenario..but since it is another family...you automatically think they are out for blood. Let a judge and jury decide from the evidence presented. We have become so desensitized to people who do look for any stupid reason to sue and get money that we are blinded to the events that really are legit. "

To: Gold Diggn wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:13 AM:

" You saw the video and the Oligs were charging the cops? What are you smoking? The family was on their way back into their home when the criminals came into the yard and assaulted the family! Sure the family was probably spouting off but words are not provocation in Indiana. The cop had NO Right in hitting the woman and the family was right in defending themselves! I hope they take these cops to the cleaners in a civil suit. "

Mike Soderquist wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:12 AM:

" "What should they have done, just lay there and let the cops beat the crap out of them? "

This is another very good point... We have a RIGHT to defend ourselves, even from police officers. There should be no charges filed against this family and I'm sorry that her sons were handcuffed before they could do more to protect their mother. "

Inocent Observer wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:11 AM:

" I agree with intellegence. I don't think we're getting the whole story here. It looks like both sides could be a fault here. I feel this should be investigated more. You can tell the Mrs is running her mouth. The attorneys are out for money and it looks like that family is to. Why would they so conveniently have a video tape? "

Hoosier wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:07 AM:

" If this happened in August,why is it just coming to light now? There is something fishy about this. I would like to hear the officers' side of the story. "

To: Intelligence (or lack of it) wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:05 AM:

" Indiana code says that mere words are not enough to provoke a physical attack. It doesn't matter what the woman said or did not say to the cop, he had no right to lash out! The man is a criminal and should lose his bade then face battery charges and be sent to jail for 6 months or so to gewt his head on straight! "

Not in Lake County! wrote on Feb 26, 2008 10:02 AM:

" GOOD JOB BOYS IN BLUE! I though pulling a gun on someone was only if your life is in danger...??? Doesn't look to me like your life was threatened!!! If a plane Joe did that, you bet he would be arrested and prosecuted! HOPEFULLY THAT HAPPENS TO THE GOOD OL' BOYS IN BLUE. YOU ARE NOT ABOVE THE LAW!!!!! "

Goodzilla wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:59 AM:

" What were they doing on scene for THIRTY TWO minutes? Escalating the situation and looking for an excuse to attack?

Professional lawmen should be capable of defusing a situation whhile avoiding confrontations. The time has obviously come for ALL cops to wear a camera while on duty. A collar-cam which is shackled around their neck during the shift. "

wow wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:59 AM:

" Hard to say what really happened. Too bad the video doesn't have sound. These people do look like hill billies and the tape does seem like they are getting very angry and yelling (I even see some arms flying around before the start to walk back to the house. However, there was no need to the type of aggressiveness used by the officers and NEVER should a weapon have been drawn. I would love to be sitting on this jury and see everything up close! "

Sherry Peterson wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:54 AM:

" Paul Oliver grew up in my neighborhood and I have known him since he was a young boy. Paul has good parents and was always a polite, good kid, who was never in trouble. After watching the video, I cannot comment because the video is very vague and you cannot see who the characters are and there is no sound. I do not know what was said or what prompted any actions but I wonder why someone would be videotaping in their front yard? I can say that I have observed Paul Oliver on an official police call and he was very professional and kind. "

Ouch wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:52 AM:

" I watched the tape too and it doesn't look like the family was out of control. It looked like they were walking away and the cop followed them. The son you can see is trying to get the cop off his mom (unsuccessfully). Then later on in the video its so bad that you can see a very young child try to get the cop off his mom. This is just sick and disturbing! That is why they say the police are not your friends!! Do not trust them because they can be as sick as any criminal, you never know! "

Ron wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:49 AM:

" I see a couple clueless people here claiming this is gold digging or that the woman deserved it. You are obviously the same kind of people that think a man hitting a woman is ok.
There is NEVER a reason for a man to hit a woman, that just shows your parents did not raise you right. I mean come on even if she ran her mouth, there is no reason to be hit, and if you watch the video he hit her; if he punched you in the face wouldn't you go back after him? "

Scary wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:35 AM:

" These guys are sworn to uphold the law? Lock them up. "

Hobart Thugs wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:28 AM:

" All 3 of the "cops" should be behind bars! Bernie Carter, do your job and prosecute these idiots. "

Gold Diggin wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:19 AM:

" I think the Oligs are just tryin to get money. The officer swung at Candace when she kept lunging at him. "

Hobart Resident wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:17 AM:

" I saw the video and I saw the Olig's repeatedly charging the cops. This looks like the Oligs were out of control. "

Linda wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:16 AM:

" So many police officers think they are above the law - they routinely break traffic laws - and if someone calls the police on something at their house, nothing is ever done because they are all in some sort of "brotherhood" with all other police officers. They all cover each others' backs even when they are doing wrong. They need to be held to a high standard - get rid of these cowboys and make them unhirable as a police officer in other towns. They just move around from city to city and keep doing the same thing. Reminds me of the Catholic Church and how they moved molesting priests from church to church. "

huh wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:11 AM:

" I really dont understand what happened...why would a cop just get out and start hitting and insulting? Theres gotta be something left out of the story. These people had to provoke it somehow. "

not surprised wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:06 AM:

" this is police brutality, they need to be punished for this. if you read this article, click on the video to see Hobart's finest beating that poor woman. and they are to protect the community, who is going to protect us from them??? "

Tim wrote on Feb 26, 2008 9:02 AM:

" Is anyone really surprised by this anymore? "

Unbiased Observer wrote on Feb 26, 2008 8:59 AM:

" Wow.... I know there are three sides to every story, but this looks bad for the police. There was no justification apparent for the first punch. "

Darla wrote on Feb 26, 2008 8:58 AM:

" I think its great the family had video tape of this and the police officers involved should face criminal prosecution and do some time if convicted of abuse. Its officers like these that give good cops a black eye. Cops complain of not getting the respect they deserve and this is a good reason why they do not. "

Thank God! wrote on Feb 26, 2008 8:58 AM:

" Thank God the Olig family was able to catch this incident on tape! What were those officers thinking? "

Hobart Res wrote on Feb 26, 2008 8:55 AM:

" It's not news to anyone who has lived in this area for some time that you're better off not asking for a report. Hobart's police force are quite capable of taking a report they are often times plain lazy and refuse. While this isn't always the case (since the newer officers are more willing than the upper ranks) it does seem to be more often than not. With these newer squad cars having computers inside it should be pretty easy. With all the nepotism and other recent controversies surrounding this perticular department it will be intresting to see how the new mayor/former chief handles the matter "

Chris wrote on Feb 26, 2008 8:53 AM:

" I was a police officer for awhile and I must say that this is a complete abuse of power. All those officers involved should be terminated and the Olig's should receive compensation for this. I'm sure the Olig's were running their mouths, but this is America. Its called free speech. There was no need to attack these people and arrest them. That officer should have NEVER pulled his gun and pointed it. There were no weapons involved in this scuffle that was instigated by these officers. Not only should they be fired, but charged with battery as well. All charges against the Olig's should be dropped. Im just in shock about this. Good thing they had that security system taping everything, because no one would believe them otherwise. Good for you guys! When you win your millions make sure to move out of Hobart! "

Dr.Pepper wrote on Feb 26, 2008 8:45 AM:

" It's a shame how today's cops are. Democracy's been dead since Nixon. "

Resident wrote on Feb 26, 2008 8:39 AM:

" Awful, just awful! They were terrorized, these people deserve big bucks for this travesty! "

Nicholas Kamm wrote on Feb 26, 2008 8:08 AM:

" I'm usually on the side of police, but that cop just full out punched her in the face! I didn't see any reason to punch a middle aged woman in the face without being physically provoked first.... I'm guessing that's not part of their training for subduing someone... "

JDub wrote on Feb 26, 2008 8:03 AM:

" It's hard for police to get rid of their bad stigma when stories like this keep popping up. Sometimes I think cops get a high off being in power and think they are invincible. "

sue wrote on Feb 26, 2008 7:50 AM:

" Sounds like a 500 million dollar case to me.
"

Keil Man wrote on Feb 26, 2008 7:33 AM:

" Looks like an open and shut case. The officer struck the first blow which should never happen. As far as the resisting and battery charges on the Oligs, it looks like they were defending themselves. What should they have done, just lay there and let the cops beat the crap out of them? "

hobart resident wrote on Feb 26, 2008 7:27 AM:

" It's hard to tell what's going on here. I know before the fight it appears that the young man walking in circles has his fists clinched? I am sure that there is more to the story than some cops addressing a call and attacking a family. I wish this video had audio! "

Ken wrote on Feb 26, 2008 6:56 AM:

" If this family did not have a video system, they would be portrayed as a group of thugs and criminals. I want to know what happened to the minor children when they were taken to jail. "

Yikes wrote on Feb 26, 2008 3:44 AM:

" I have to tell you that this scares me.
I live in Hobart, and quite frankly if this is what's going on my town, I'm not too happy with it.

Sad thing is, I voted for the present mayor. I've yet to read anything good or positive on what's he's done.

At least the LAST mayor would return phone calls that were made to them. If you called the town, things got done. Now...

What has this world come to? "

Home Invasion wrote on Feb 26, 2008 3:42 AM:

" As far as I'm concerned, the moment that officer stepped onto the property, it became a home invasion. "

Back to story 287 comment(s)

Post a comment Once your comments are approved, they will appear here.

Marketplace

Sections

Services

Other Publications

Search